I bought this eyeliner to try it out and it was horrible.

pros:
- cheap
- small/cute packaging

cons:
- slightly watery
- would go all over my lids when i blinked
- would stick to the crease on my lids

this product is pretty much waterproof. it took many wipes of eye make up remover to take it off - and unfortunately, it took off a few of my eyelashes.haven't used it since and i would not buy it again.

EDIT: i watched a video of someone who really liked this product and i gave it another try. i bought a darker color - dark brown - and tried it again. it's actually not that bad. another brush is recommended - a more precise brush. the brush it has originally is entirely coated with the liner and thus - creates horrible lines. one thing i love about this, is that it is COMPLETELY WATERPROOF. i had to use several tries at make up remover to get it off, and there is still a thin line on my lash line. THE SMUDGING PROBLEM: a way to fix it - for me - is to just wait for the liner to set. allow 20 seconds for it to completely dry before opening your eyes completely.

IF you want a waterproof eyeliner, you must try this.it has it's quirks but ultimately, it's a REALLY good waterproof liquid liner.

This is an average eyeliner. It will stay maybe 3/4 of the day on my oily, Asian half-monolids, but it eventually fades and transfers onto my lower lid. Because it is waterproof, I have to use vaseline to remove it, and it does not come right off. Packaging is kind of cheap, so the product starts to dry out and gets sticky after a few months so that the application isn't smooth anymore. I recommend the Revlon Colorstay Liquid Liner--it's much better.

I thought I would NEVER get it off...had to use two different kinds of eye makeup remover and it took 10 minutes. I didn't think it looked that bad, but it is not worth the trouble to remove it.

I wanted to love this because it's cheap and I like WnW stuff, but nope. The applicator is not so much a "brush".. it's pretty solid. That allows for some precision, but unfortunately the color is so crappy it doesn't matter. It's just a streaky mess. And if you try to go over it to fill in said streaks, it just pushes the color around and it's just as streaky. (And yes, I did shake it before applying as it instructs on the bottle.)

I can't comment on anything else because it looks so crappy it's unwearable for me.

I must admit that I had low expectations for this. I mean, come on, it costs two bucks. But I was in desperate need of a liquid eyeliner, and so I just picked up the cheapest one I could find. Good thing I did! This is without doubt the longest-wearing eyeliner I've ever come across. It stays on all day, even around the inner and outer corners of the waterline (this is quite an accomplishment; my waterline is normally very oily) This beats Urban Decay's 24/7 pencils and Mac's Liquidlast Liner. This can clearly be a bad point for some people, since it is difficult to remove, but for me, it's the holy grail of eyeliners. It's nicely pigmented, doesn't feel heavy, doesn't make my eyes water, and lasts. So who cares if its packaging may not be the best? I recommend using a long, thin gel eyeliner brush if you're not good with bigger applicators such as the one that comes with this.

The only thing i like about this is what it looks like. This is all i have to say
-Eyeliner applier is WAY 2 pointy & hard
- Eyeliner sucks: Its way 2 sticky (it stuck 2 my top lids, making it come off on my lids, not where i put it) and Wont come off, unless u PULL ur lids.
-If it gets on your lashes, dont even think about putting on mascara. it will make it CLUMPY and MESSED UP.

VERY upset with this product. Plz dont get it, dont waste your time.
continued >>

A lot of times I find that some cheap makeup is better than the more expensive stuff. Not with this product. It smudged fast, made my eyes feel weird, can't get fine lines, and it was hard to get off because it's waterproof. I'll admit getting a waterproof eyeliner was my own fault, but this stuff was still bad regardless.

Love this product! I use it on my water line every day( even though I know you're not supposed to put liquid liner on your water line, but it's the only thing that stays!) However, I have very sensitive skin and eyes so unless i layer it on top of my Almay liner. It's the only liner I've ever used that actually stays on all day!

RIS, we don't have wet n wild in Singapore and i was grateful that a nice MUA-er sent this for me to try out. OMG! the product is so affordable and it withstand tears, smudging in this humid weather.It's jet black, great for tight lining. Easy to remove, with little effort. It's even darker than MAC blacktrack. I am thinking pin up look.

This is extremely cheap. If you're just starting with eyeliner, it's good to try this out. But after wearing this for a couple of hours it smudges and you can see it on your crease already. :[ Not fun at all. It doesn't really dry that fast and sometimes when it dries it dries to a shiny finish. I'd rather use Jordana Fabuliner.