This concealer goes on thick enough and it stays on for hours, and I love how moisturizing it is at first, however after a while it turns too cakey and light on me. Maybe the shade I chose was too light for me, nevertheless I wouldnt risk buying a darker shade, since I had another neutrogena concealer and it did the same "cakey" look on me :/

I was looking for a reasonably priced eye concealer that also contained an SPF. This neutrogena concealer in a tube I LOVE! I have oily skin & a light olive complexion. A little bit goes a long way w/ this concealer. It does not cake-up or leave a crease on your eyelid like many others do. I have no complaints regarding this product. continued >>

I absolutely love this. It's my HG under-eye EVERYTHING pretty much, and has been for years. It has a thicker consistency so it works well to conceal, has SPF, and not to mention hydrating. Definitely a staple in my collection since it's such a no-brained.

bad bad bad.
i'm oily and this managed to dry my skin out after one use.
it covered decently, but the drying effect made my fine lines look worse than they really are. and i looked tired. yuck.

LOVE IT! So this stuff is really creamy and it covers my dark circles as well as the redness around my nose really well! I gave it a 4 simply because I need to use thicker concealer for any blemishes that may pop up, but this concealer is perfect for everyday wear. I love that it has SPF and it is very moisturizing. I have very very dry skin and the skin around my eyes is especially sensitive and usually is the first to become dry throughout the day. This concealer has definitely improved the look at feel of my skin throughout the day and I don't feel that it clogs my pores like other, thicker concealers do. Will buy this stuff for years to come and recommend it for everyday wear. LOVE IT!

I bought this product and it is absolutely amazing! Yes, it is specified to be used under the eyes, but I use this for blemishes and redness like a regular concealer. It is very pigmented and the colors go well with every skintone. It also says that it is an eye cream which is great and contains sun protection which I hardly wear, but great that it contains it. Overall, great product.

I have to agree with some people here. I have this in the lightest shade (I think it's in Fair). It goes on a bit chalky and it looks a little unnatural to me. It's not bad but it's definitely not the best product out there. You do get a lot of product and I really liked the idea though being a 3 in 1 sort of thing, but I think it's just not that great. I've heard that it's better to use salmon instead of using a very light shade. I'll try that next time as this product did not do it completely for me.

Consistency makes it a little too thick for application around the eyes and the color is a bit chalky for the areas of the face where you would want something slightly more opaque (I tried, thinking that I could find another use for for it.) So, no, would definitely not repurchase as a concealer. Because I am loathe to throw anything out, I found that it worked best as an eyeshadow base.

This was a fair-good concealer. It lessened the appearance of my tired eyes and dark circles. But I hate putting it on! Sometimes it gets a bit dry under the eyes and make the lines visable and powdery looking. But other than that, it did help some.

I mean, this concealer is fairly good for a ds brand and does not break me out (which is a giant plus) but it's just to sheer for me. The formula is sheer, yet at the end of the day, it gives off a look of cakey makeup. Its nice that is has spf and it blends into my skin really well, but personally, I need more coverage for my under eye circles. I will still use it though until I can find something better.