This concealer doesn't have the best coverage-- I have used many concealers with more coverage than this one. But what's great about this one is that it's not drying, doesn't settle into lines, and looks very natural. The package claims that this is also an eye cream but this would definitely not be moisturizing enough for me by itself, I use an eye cream underneath. The coverage is slightly buildable but I wouldn't advise applying more than one layer as it will look cakey and unnatural if you apply too much. I also use this on my upper eyelids and it makes a good base for shadow and liner. Overall I like this and will continue to use until I find something with better coverage that looks just as natural.
Normally I use a Body Shop under eye concealer but I needed something more creamy that covered some of the bluish hue under my eyes. This works amazing! I don't find that it's dry at all or that it cakes under my eyes. I have it in the Light shade and it covers well on those mornings that my eyes look a bit tired. I even use this around my nose, mouth and chin to cover up the redness.
I may be in my early twenties but I have under eye circles. Nothing covers them up. This might be good for light to mild issues (hence the 3) but definitely not heavy under eye circles. I have since moved on.
4/28/12: My old review was written in 2009. I have since re-tried this concealer and it is just not for me. There's a lack of coverage, lasting, and it just isn't the best.
As the previous reviewer stated, this concealer does the job and then some! It conceals my under eye dark circles completely. Protects from the sun and moisturizes very well. Doesn't wear off or crease. Surpising since I have always had a problem with concealer and make-up creasing under my eyes. Not greasy and not too $$. The tube dispenser makes it very sanitary btw!
OK 1) this is a concealer 2) this is an eye cream 3) it has SPF 20!!! This concealer is very creamy and moisturizing and it doesn't settle into any liittle fine lines you may have. It has spf 20 which is great! One thing I hate sometimes about under eye concealers is that sometimes that cover up too much and it looks unnatural. I know that sounds crazy but I hate when it covers up so well that it looks weird. I don't know maybe that's just me but really, naturally the skin under your eye is a little bit of a different color. This concealer, it covers up the darkness great and it really brightens them + it is good for your skin. This is a teeny bit light for me but i still like it.
Update 8/20/09: As I said this was a little light for me, and now that it is summer it is really really light for me. However, I still have the little tube and it is nowhere near finished off, So I have started using this with my MAC Studio Sculpt Concealer
I found that, alone under the eyes, the Studio Sculpt concealer was a little dry and cakey looking. Well if I mix a little of this with the studio sculpt, it works beautifully and it is the correct color for me.
This concealer goes on thick enough and it stays on for hours, and I love how moisturizing it is at first, however after a while it turns too cakey and light on me. Maybe the shade I chose was too light for me, nevertheless I wouldnt risk buying a darker shade, since I had another neutrogena concealer and it did the same "cakey" look on me :/
I was looking for a reasonably priced eye concealer that also contained an SPF. This neutrogena concealer in a tube I LOVE! I have oily skin & a light olive complexion. A little bit goes a long way w/ this concealer. It does not cake-up or leave a crease on your eyelid like many others do. I have no complaints regarding this product.
I absolutely love this. It's my HG under-eye EVERYTHING pretty much, and has been for years. It has a thicker consistency so it works well to conceal, has SPF, and not to mention hydrating. Definitely a staple in my collection since it's such a no-brained.
bad bad bad.
i'm oily and this managed to dry my skin out after one use.
it covered decently, but the drying effect made my fine lines look worse than they really are. and i looked tired. yuck.
LOVE IT! So this stuff is really creamy and it covers my dark circles as well as the redness around my nose really well! I gave it a 4 simply because I need to use thicker concealer for any blemishes that may pop up, but this concealer is perfect for everyday wear. I love that it has SPF and it is very moisturizing. I have very very dry skin and the skin around my eyes is especially sensitive and usually is the first to become dry throughout the day. This concealer has definitely improved the look at feel of my skin throughout the day and I don't feel that it clogs my pores like other, thicker concealers do. Will buy this stuff for years to come and recommend it for everyday wear. LOVE IT!