The length this gives, omg. LOVE. This may be expensive, but I'm definitely repurchasing. Soooo worth it!

I have allergy eyes and I don't usually wear eye make up. I got a sample YSL mascara and found it very comfortable, no eye-irritation or what-so-ever. So I decided to purchase a YSL mascara, and I picked this one since I have very small eyes and short, thin lashes. I'm not disappointed with this product at all! I wear it daily, and I just dab it on my lashes with small touches, only one layer does it to get a natural make-up, longer, fuller -but not so over-the-top lashes. Extra layering gives more definition and more of a false-lashes look. Definitely recommend to those with allergy eyes and contact lense wearers.

I bought this mascara with high expectations given the price I paid for it as well as the rave reviews it got - but Im really disappointed. As another reviewer said - it clumps in the tube and on the wand, and most frustratingly on my lashes ! I wish I had just just bought 2 bottles of Maybelline or Covergirl mascara instead , they do more for my lashes than this overpriced thing did !!

This is my favourite mascara and the only one I've bought more than once. It doen't give me clumpy, spidery, crispy lashes which I find that a lot of mascaras do. It makes my lashes feathery. It's good on volume but so-so on lengthening.

I love the way they make my lashes look but it's a crying shame that this mascara doesn't last as long as others. The brush and/or the formula gets all clumpy/dry/unsuable over time which really, really sucks considering how much it costs! This is why the mascara gets 4 lippies instead of 5.

For me this left me underwhelmed. It was nothing special it dried out my lashes and in the tube I much prefer my beloved Mac haute & naughty mascara.For me this left me underwhelmed. It was nothing special it dried out my lashes and in the tube I much prefer my beloved Mac haute & naughty mascara. continued >>

This is the worst mascara I have ever used, its not even as good as ASDA's own brand! It didnt actually look like I had mascara on, no length, no volume. I didnt even think it was very black, it looks more grey really and it smudged and flaked after about an hour. It also dries out on my lashes and in the container very quickly. The packaging is really nice though!

Clumpy. Doesn't smudge. Makes my lashes look thicker in a trashy way. Not classy. Not what I want from YSL.

Update: rating reduced even further. I just used this mascara again, admittedly after leaving it (sealed) for a couple of months. My eyes are a thick sticky black mess. I have to remove my makeup and start again. I've thrown this expensive away after using it half a dozen times max. Not impressed.

I love this mascara. Really did wonders in terms of both lengthening and thickening. I would definitely buy again.

I loved this mascara for about one application. It is thick, and does give high impact. If you curl it afterwards, tends to leave a line in the lash. Not pretty.

Also, it dried out very quickly, and clumped on my average lashes like crazy. Lovely smell, nice and dark pigments, but I am actually happier with my Rimmel Max Bold Curves Mascara for about a third the price. And it lasts three times as long.

I've tried many mascaras in the past but always go back to this one. Makes the lashes longer and doesnt smudge. It also hydrates the lashes and doesnt break them. For best results, use a eyelash curler prior applying it and you will see a huge difference. Amazing!!