This is deffinately my go to liner. It stays on for hours, and doesn't flake, or smudge. Recently I started using this in my waterline, and it's wonderful...stays on better than any pencil. Great product!

If you have an oily face, and looking for the real long lasting for 10hrs this is not the option. It only last 3hrs for me. It smudge so bad. And if you don't close it tight it will dries and harden. I still searching for an eyeliner that can last at least 10hrs beside estee

This is a good choice when you want like a certain shade of dark brown or a very complex shade of eyeliner. A lot of the times this is true with the high-end brand products. The quality of the product may be the same to that of a drugstore product but you willl have better choices with color.

Although this eyeliner is super creamy, it does not have staying power.
Even with primer, I did not find that it stayed on.
It would smudge within an hour without a primer, but with primer it would last maybe 4 hours.
I was very disappointed.

This is meant to be one of the best award winning gel eyeliners but I don't know how. I found it to be anything but what it claims. I have tried a few gel eyeliners (Mac Fluidline, Kate etc...) that were better and cheaper.
It glided on quite nicely at the start but within minutes it had transferred to my upper eyelids. Then it smudged, streaked and just did not stay on where it should have. I created the cats eye look but the wings just disappeared. By the end of my night out I came home with panda eyes. Boy, was I not happy!
I tried it again but had the same result. This eyeliner is quite expensive and did not live up to expectation, will not use again.

I have this in 2 colors: black ink and chocolate shimmer ink. This is hands down the best gel eyeliner out there. I've used Mac, ELF, Maybelline....nothing else compares. Yes this is expensive, but it's a huge amount of product, and the quality makes it worth it. I've had mine for about 2 months now, and it's still as good as new. I prefer this to the other brands mentioned above, because this is, imo, a true "gel" eyeliner. The other ones feel much more like a cream. Which is fine, but the line then tends to go on a little thick and a little cakey. I prefer to build up my liner depending on how dramatic I want my look to be. And this definitely does that. Plus, it doesn't budge, doesn't irritate my waterline...it's just fab. Bobbi Brown may not be the most "exciting" cosmetic brand out there, but the woman really knows how to create very subtle, wearable makeup with quality formulas.

I usded to use the gel one by Bobbi Brown a few years ago and remember loving it. So i thought let me get another one to use in my waterline as i loved it before. Bad move they have changed something and now its way to creamy runs every where and when used as eyeliner on my eye lids it just smudged and did not stay in place i could not beleive this was the same one i used to use before so dissapointed.

I was really underwhelmed by this, yes it is creamy and decently pigmented but staying power was pretty bad. I like my winged liner to have a nice sharp point and stay nice and crisp all day but this fades really easily. Not worth the money IMO

This by far is the best eyeliner I have used. I find the packaging super cute. I specially love its in glass. This liner gives you the look of liquid liner with the ease and feel of a gel formula. This is so long-wearing, it lasts forever. Its water resistant color and glides on beautifully. It lets you get it just right before it dries-then stays without a smear or crease. I use this in Black Ink. I'm obsessed with it.

I have used Bobbi Brown's Long-Wear gel eyeliner for several years now and in the past I've absolutely LOVED it! This year though not so much. Have they changed the formulation?? I usually use Black Mauve shimmer ink which goes with everything and occasionally Black plum. Both formulations have been so dry right out of the jar. It has nothing to do with me leaving the lid off. These formulations used to be great but I'm having a hard time getting my brush into the product. I asked the sales rep if they are changing out the supply because I'm starting to wonder if I'm getting old product. I may start using Mac's fluid line more but there is no comparison to the pretty colors in the Bobbi Brown line!