I was really disappointed with this. Its probably the worst product i have ever bought from MAC. Its clumpy, the brush makes it hard to apply and the product is too wet that it just makes a mess if you have long eyelashes like me. It doesnt really lengthen or make your lashes look thick and full - it just makes a clumpy mess. I have tried so hard to like it but most of the time it just looks horrible. The only good thing about it is that its very black. Its quite expensive and definitely not worth it. I wont be buying this again.

This mascara is great if you want that clumpy look. That probably sounds like a joke, but I'm actually being serious. The girl at the MAC counter put it on me and the look she created (purposely) was over-the-top clumped lashes. I obviously didn't want that, but I bought it anyway figuring I'd just apply it differently and get the feathery look I like in mascaras. It is, to put it lightly, difficult for me to get it to do anything other than clump. I can normally get just about any mascara to look good, but this one requires significantly more work than all of the drugstore brands I've tried. Two stars because it IS possible to get it to work, it's just a lot harder than with any of the multitude of other (cheaper) mascaras I've tried.

This mascara last for many hours with my MAC matching eyeliner, which makes my eyes really pop very much. It doesn't smudge and it is waterproof. It maxumizes my eyelashes and make them longer (even like fdake eyelashes) even better than the Maybelline falsies which is also good.

Awful! I think this is simultaneously the most expensive and worst mascara I have tried. It does a great job of instantly clumping my lashes together. Does seem to lengthen & curl lashes somewhat but this is pointless when my lashes look like spider legs! A waste of money, would not recommend.

Didn't clump like everyone says. It worked like any other mascara so it was nothing special. The only real complaint I have is that it doesn't last as long as my other mascaras. I didn't even use it as much, maybe like 3-4 times a week and it ran out after a couple months. My maybelline or cover girl mascaras usually last at least 6 months.

Great for an everyday mascara but this didn't give me the length or fullness I want from my mascara. I will use up but won't repurchase.

I had a small sample size of this awhile ago. It was horrible! I usually like MAC products, but this I wouldn't waste my money on. Doesn't do much for my short lashes and clumped pretty badly too. Not sure if it was because of my small sample sized tube, but it dries out quickly. Better off buying a drugstore one since you need to replace mascara's often.

I feel the this mascara is at the same level as maybelline ds mascara. No need to waste your money on this, does the same as what maybelline falsies does.

I cant believe this is rated so low!!! This is my HG mascara. I gave it four bc I believe somehow there IS better out there. It gives me volume, length with limited clumping. I got a trial in a holiday pack. Im on my 10th one or so. Reasonably priced

Awful. That is the only word I have for this junk. It makes my lashes clump together BADLY, and it makes them look all spidery and gross. I feel like I gave it a fair chance by using it for several days in a row and I just couldn't do it. So I took it back today and got mascara x. The reviews look pretty good so hopefully I like it.