I love this makeup remover. The oil helps take away all the waterproof and long lasting makeup. With just one swipe to your eyes, practically everything will come off with very little makeup remaining. It's such a great product. I have repurchased this twice already. & even if there isn't the Neutrogena brand, there is always a cheaper which works just as well (:

Not exactly oil free. In fact I found it pretty oily. The makeup removing power is just so so. sometimes it leaves me dry eyes after using it. will not repurchase.

i have been using this product regularly for over 4 years and i am really happy with it. i am not sure if i would change it sometime because in the future i may try a product for aging skin. but it is perfect for young skin!!!

A definite drug-store winner!!! It's something I'm always going to have and repurchase. A staple in my makeup remover army.

PROS:
Affordable
Easy to find/ always in stock
Works great!
Oil-free formula is what I need for my lash extensions
Not harsh
No strong smell
Good amount of product in the bottle
No icky residue

CONS:
This isn't REALLY a con b/c it's virtually IMPOSSIBLE to remove a lot of WP Japanese mascaras (especially my Majolica Majorca - truly bulletproof this one is) but yeah, it doesn't remove them ...by itself that is. The trick is to add a little bit of OLIVE OIL to the cotton swab along with the Neutrogena Oil-Free remover and you let your lashes soak for a min and it'll come off...eventually haha.

Will I repurchase? YES!!!!

I love I love this product. It erases my makeup gently and its cheaper than other good makeup removers.

Excellent product. I had started to have some problems with biphasic makeup removers. I needed them to remove my waterproof makeup but they were causing me nasty allergic reactions on my eyelids. Besides, these kind of makeup removers tend to leave a not very attractive sensation of oil on your skin.
I solved these problems with Neutrogena Oil Free eye makeup remover. No more allergic reaction, cool sensation on my skin and perfect to remove waterproof makeup. It has almost no smell. You can use it on your eyelids and on your face too.
Some people have mentioned the product leaves your skin oily. But if read the instructions (in the package that is sold in Argentina, at least), you'll notice that you have to wash out your face after using it. By doing that, you won't feel any oily sensation on your face or eyelids.
Of course, I'll repurchase.

I bought this yesterday and tried it out to remove my non-waterproof mascara, which usually removes easily. I saturated a piece of cotton, and held it on my eyelashes for 10seconds, then proceeded to wipe gently... I was NOT happy to have a bunch of my eyelashes start to fall out. I had 4-5 per eye fall out as I was trying to remove the mascara...I even used more product to really soak the mascara when doing the second eye and same situation. I will try this again tomorrow to see if maybe it was just a coincidence, but if not I will most stop using.

Edit** I thought this remover was semi-decent but have since moved on to other things. I'm currently using Vichy and really like it

Great make-up remover! Works quickly, and does a thorough job. Even removes eyeliner! I have issues with eyeliner because it is so close to my actual eye that I don't want to scrub at it, and this always just strips it right off! It's amazing.

I really like this makeup remover. It takes everything off my skin, works really well and is fairly cheap. Plus, you get a good amount of product in the bottle, so it lasts FOREVER. The only issue I have is that it makes my skin feel oily after I use it, which other removers I've used haven't done. But, it's worth it.

Way too oily feeling for me. It does a good job taking eye makeup off, however leaves this grosse oily film around my eyes. I noticed small bumps around my eyes after using this product a few times.