i dont use eyemakeup removers, but my best friend swears by this one and i have used it before also. does a good job of getting all the traces of dark makeup off your lids.

I have been buying this for the last year and would buy again as soon as i run out. This removes makeup perfectly, i actually like the oily consistence.

Pros:
-Removes my eye makeup immediately
-Best drugstore eye makeupremover

Cons:
-Makes your eyelids super oily. It kinda gets annoying as you have to rub your eyes a lot to wash off the oil.
-Kinda stings my eyes

Great value product. Only complaint is it is VERY oily feeling. My eyes actually sting because it starts to get into them if I don't quickly rinse with water after applying.

LOVE IT! The best eye makeup remover I've ever used. I wouldn't say is "Oil-free" because it does leave an oily-watery residue, but you can clean it up with a tissue and there you go!

I like it because is very gentle and removes even waterproof mascara without pulling out your eyelashes (let's face it, we've all have used crappy eye makeup removers that do work terribly)

I definitely recommend it.

Oil-free? You've got to be kidding! Maybe technically, there isn't any oil. But this stuff definitely feels oily. And you can SEE the oil-water separation!!

However, it works well for removing my modest eye makeup (just eyeliner). I just need to use 1 or 2 Q-tips and I'm done. It also removes the thick BB cream I use as a concealer. No need to rub at the delicate skin under my eyes.

Boring product, but does the job. I can't give it 5 lippies coz I feel Neutrogena is taking me for an idiot by claiming this product is oil-free.

I am very particular as to how I remove my eye make up. I have very sensitive eyes and try to use gentle products. Olive Oil is not for me, so I resorted to this product. Its a basic and it seems like everyone uses it. I'd say its a basic, simple eye make up remover that gets the job done, just not as well as I'd like it to. I think its not thorough enough and often it doesn't get all my make up off. Its not a favorite, but I'll still use it!

I love this product. I saturate a cotton pad and place it on each eye for 30 seconds and it takes off everything. No tugging or pulling, ever.

Frankly, this stuff sucks. I don't wear a spectacular amount of eye makeup on a daily basis so I shouldn't have to rub or scrub my eyes to remove my mascara.

This makeup remover is the best!! Ive tried high end products similar to this but for the price and convienence, this is one is perfect! It gets all of my eye makeup off gently and does not leave a gross residue.