Its the best eye pencil ive tried solely for the fact that it last longer than the rest on my waterline. Im definitely not saying it last all day, but its much better than the others. I tried stila kajal and the colors are absolutely gorgeous but there isnt a chance of it staying. I also tried urban decays 24/7 pencil which stays just about as long as this one but the color was not dark enough for me and it wasnt as creamy. The powerpoint seems to have the best of each of those. Also a range of pretty colors.
This is the best eye liner I have ever used. It lasts all day or night and stays on after I get out of the shower. Would definatley recommend for anyone who uses eyeliner daily. If you put a little liquid liner over it it will reaaallly last and not smudge.
Ok, so main the main thing I want with an eye liner is staying power on the water line (also smudge free). This looks great when just applied, but eventually on me it smudges under my eyes. I think I might try putting a teeny bit of blot powder over this to see if it helps, because I'm starting to think that maybe the skin around my eyes is oily.
If anyone knows of an eyeliner that really stays on your water line, could you tell me, please?
This pencil is okay. Nothing great. It's not as intense as I expected it to be and doesn't last very long on the waterline at all. Would not buy again. Smolder is better.
it actually did smudge, even after i apply UDPP. I guess it really depends on your eyes. My friend used it and she loved it, but for me it didn't work out.
This is my FAVORITE eyeline of all time!!!! And trust me, I've tried many!!! It's smooth, long-lasting, and smudge-free!! Can you ask for anything more? It's a bit "creamier" than regular eyeliners but I love it!! I also love this color because it's a smokey dark grayish-black (sorry, it's the best way I can describe the color). I recently bought MAC's regular eyeline but was not impressed! Powerpoint Engraved is the best!!
This eyeliner smudges and does not have long staying power. I use it if I'm in a hurry. For staying power, you can't beat fluidline gel eyeliner.
it stays but fades. very creamy but when sharpening you lose a lot of product. should of got the mac technakohl eye liner instead.
This is my very first eyeliner from Mac. It's also the one that I buy the most once it runs out. I love how the color is really black and how smoothly this pencil draws on my lids. This liner does stay all does but has the tendency to fade over time. Therefore going from very black to off black. Overall... I still love the pencil.
This pencil is nearly identical to Prestige's Waterproof Eyeliner. I had read that this liner was similar to Prestige, which I already had as an HG. I thought I would get the MAC and just use the Prestige as a backup but the opposit has happened.
To compare the two:
Engraved is the same intense black as Prestige Waterproof and exactly the same beautiful line. There is seriously no difference between the two in terms of how it looks.
Engraved is softer than Prestige but not in a good way. Prestige is very soft and easy too apply. Engraved is so soft that it is easy to make mistakes.
Engraved wears away and smudges even with UDPP while Prestige lasts the whole day when combined with UDPP.
Engraved is 3x the cost of the Prestige liner!
So in a nutshell, not only is the Prestige liner identical to this, it out performs it and it is about a third of the cost.
I had heard Prestige was identical to this and was not going to even bother to try Engraved. I should have just not bothered. I can't believe a drugstore pencil is that much better than MAC, but it's true. Save your $ ladies!