It's a little pricy, but to me it's deifintely worth it. This is amazing, it's dark and pigmented, and it goes on so easily. But the waterproofness (is that even a word?) okay, it's not super waterproof because It washes off if I wash my face, but you will be able to stand getting water on your face without worrying about it melting off your face. But I reaaaally really like this.
I feel like I've spent my whole life in search of this eyeliner. Talk about HG material! I've been wearing eyeliner virtually every single day for the last 8 years (a cat-eye for the last 2) and this is the first one that glides on with ease. It's waterproof, doesn't fade (stays super dark even after 12+ hours of wear on my oily lids), and doesn't irritate my eyes. HG HG HG.
this liner was okay. it didnt stay all day for me
True to name, this eyeliner really does stay all day and doesn't smudge even on my oily lids. Deep black pigmentation but the finish is a bit shiny. I took a lippy off because after I had had it for a while, it wouldn't apply as smoothly and I would have to go over the same line multiple times.
I have to admit that the reviews were right on for this product. I have been searching for the perfect black eyeliner and while this one isn't perfect, it is pretty darn close. I like that the tip like a felt tip marker, which is pretty popular these days but the tip is long and slender enabling a nice, tight line that can be drawn slender or heavy, depending on the look you want to achieve. I purchased in black and it is a nice dramatic black without glitter or grayish tones but a deep carbon black. I did subtract one lippie because it will rub off if you tend to rub your eyes a lot. I have been experiencing seasonal allergies and have rubbed my eyes more than usual the past 2 days and when I look in the mirror come late afternoon, my eyeliner seems to have disappeared from my inner eye area. This was my only complaint and was minor but I hope when I find my perfect eyeliner it will withstand my allergies and resulting itchy eyes.
Best liquid liner I've ever used! This is my hg. It goes on so smoothly and lasts all day long. The skinny tip makes thick or thin lines so easy.
This is a very good eyeliner. I manage to make any and everything flake or smudge off my lids by the end of the day. This is nearly as good as my favorite eyeliner, MAC's blacktrack. This Stila liner makes up for the teensy bit of inferiority compared to MAC with its smooth, even application and ease of use for doing cat eye. Also, it doesn't require me to carry a separate brush with me as the blacktrack does. I have had it for a year, using it relatively frequently, and it hasn't run out or dried up on me. I recommend!
Given the high reviews on MUA, I decided to try this and I can definitely say, I am not disappointed. So far, every Stila eye product that I have purchased has always lived up to its name. This liquid eyeliner has become my everyday eye liner product. I don't line my entire eye but only at the end and draw a wing. At the end of the day, there is minimal smudging due to the hot and humid weather. But for majority of the time, it is still good and fresh by the time the day is over. So far, this liquid eyeliner lives up to its name and has worked for me. I think I will keep using this and probably repurchase because of all the other liquid eyeliners I've tried. Thank you, Stila!
This is an amazing eyeliner and I love how its so easy to carry around. Unfortunately, without a primer, the 'stay all day' part doesn't really work out on my oily lids. It starts chipping away in a few hours. But a little bit of primer does the trick.
i was looking for an eyeliner that lasts all day without smudging and i found THE ONE. im a liquid eyeliner girl who wings out the liner and usually by the middle of the day, the wings are gone. they suggested this at sephora and boy am i impressed!! at the end of the day my wing is still in tact :) i love it, a little on the pricey side ($20 @ sephora) but worth it. i dont know how long the actual product lasts as i just purchased it. the marker itself is great, i find it slim and comparable to loreals slim eyeliner, but with a better formula.