LOVE LOVE LOVE - pigmented and super long lasting - this is the only eyeliner that doesn't smudge on my asian eyes and i have used (Bobbi Brown, Mac gel liners, Urban decay, MUFE eyeliners).
This is a very good liquid eyeliner; I am very impressed with it! I wear it on top of UDPP and it doesn't smudge or flake. I wore it to a party that went late, and went to sleep in it (just that one time, I swear!), and when I woke up the next afternoon, it was still where I put it - it cracked a bit at the wing, but it didn't flake off or smudge at all! Very impressive coming from someone with SUPER notoriously oily skin/eyelids. Application is super easy with the stiff, sharp tip and OH, it dries SUPER fast, which is an important feature for me who has hooded lids and is always on a rush. I gave it a 4 instead of 5 because of the price ($30 from Sephora) and I think Revlon or L'oreal has (or had) a comparable liquid eyeliner, I just can't remember which one.
I bought this because the good reviews. The staying powder is great, and also great for the sexy cat eyes. However, the first one I purchased from the drugstore dried out in one week, no matter how I shake it, there's no product coming out. So I went back to exchange for another one, the SA told me that the pen had to be placed vertically to ensure that there is always enough product on the tip. I personally find it annoying because I always carry my makeup around but in this case I have to leave it at home. The price will be fair if it can last for a while, the packaging is ok, the tip cover has cracked in a month, so I suggest you have to be more gentle when you place the cover on the tip.
Overall a great product, would purchase another one if i can't find replacement.
Update: I can't wait to update my rating from 4 lipsticks to 1, because my liner finally ran out today. This time doesn't matter how I shake it, wet the brush, rinse with water (I've always kept it standing in the jar like SA suggested), first there were some grayish ink came out then nothing at all, so I know it ran out. After two times of exchanging the product (first time the ink dried out in one week, second time the lid cracked after one use), the third one lasted about 3 months. BUT WAIT, I only use it ONCE OR TWICE a week, so do the math! The $30 tag for only this amount of product is ridiculous, to me it's not even worth $10 now. For few dollars extra, my last Chanel liquid liner pen lasted me over a year, and I was using it daily.
I don't care about the nice look it gives and the long lasting power at this point, there is no way I will ever buy it again. In fact, after all the previous disappointments I had with Stila's products, I'm saying goodbye to this brand for good!
I love this eyeliner! It's very long lasting and creates the effect that I desire. Price is a bit much, but the product is good.
This eyeliner is THE best, and I have wasted money on them all. The black is a basic necessity, but the white, periwinkle and green are great too
This is very good for a liquid liner- it stays on quite well compared to other kinds I've tried, and is easier to use than gel liner with a brush. It does flake off a bit on the corners, but still performs better than any other liquid I've tried.
This eyeliner is amazing!! HG product! The felt tip is SO precise and gentle. You can draw the smallest most light line, or press harder and draw a thicker line. It's the best applicator I've ever seen. It dries very quickly so have q-tips on hand if you usually make mistakes. It is definitely waterproof, it won't come off without makeup remover. Though, recently I used it down south and it takes a little while longer to dry in the humidity, and sunscreen makes it smudge (might be the oil in the sunscreen). Definitely the best eyeliner I've ever used though. You can try it at Sephora if you're not sure about it. It's pretty expensive, about 30$ (Canada).. but I would say it's worth it. You could always order online or buy it in the States!
Absolutely amazing product. Really makes it easy to line the eyes with the fine-tipped felt applicator. Color does last all day and is easy to remove.
My absolute favourite eyeliner in the world, dark black and glossy and goes on super sleek and stays on all day. Absolutely amazing. my HG for sure.
Amazing eyeliner. I work in a cosmetic store that sells Stila and I always recommend this eyeliner to anyone looking for a liquid liner. Especailly people who are new to applying line because the felt tip point makes it easy to press on the side and get the perfect straight line. It stays on perfectly the whole day, no smudging.