For this gel liner, I've gone through 3 jars (on my 4th one now), and I must say, for a drugstore gel liner, this is definitely worth every penny. It glides on nicely and very smooth. Although, it doesn't last very long (for me), maybe because I have oily skin, I'm not so sure.
I must also add that it's nice that a brush comes with it.
I would recommend this product if you're on a budget and don't want to spend $20+
My favorite eyeliner ever!! Its so dark and long lasting! Great for a school day!
Great product. Easy to apply and stays put. Love it!
This gel eyeliner is one of the best I have ever tried. I have used the MAC gel eyeliner it is expensive and it dries out way too fast. This eyeliner is affordable and it is creamy, long lasting and super easy to apply.
I got this in charcoal. I like that it comes with a brush but really that's about it. Instead of being a nice charcoal shade it almost has hughes of blue. Not diggin that at all.
It was just okay for me. It doesn't smear off which is great. However, the color could be more pigmented. The brush it came with was just garbage. But the product was okay for the price. I think I will stick with my mac gel liners for now.
I'm another one who uses this for the brows lol
My eyebrows are a little too light and sparse for my liking so I've always filled them in and added a lil extra color. This stuff works amazing for ths purpose and its got lasting power....I just use a eyebrow brush I've had forever.put a lil bit of this creme and its perfection!!!! The color looks nice and natural...not overdone at all.
In short, I don't like it as an eyeliner but I think it is great for brow gel! Read on if you want to find out more!
At first I purchased this to use as a dupe for Bobbi Brown gel liner or my MAC fluidline. No, it is a lot more matte and less pigmented than those 2. So I had this stored away away for the longest time until I came across a brow tutorial on youtube where a girl was using a wet n wild gel liner in a brown shade using a slanted brow brush. So I decided to break out my Maybelline Eyestudio Drama in brown and use her technique on my brows. Wow! It was great for defining my shape and filling in spaces. So while I would not use this for my eyeliner i would most definitely use this for my brows!
I so wanted to like this product since I was in the market for a black upper liner and the price and reviews were great. Unfortunately, for me, this product irritated my eyes and smudged after only 3-4 hours. I gave it 2 stars because the color payoff was good prior to the fail.
I purchased this gel eyeliner after using Tarte's gel eyeliner from Sephora because I wanted to find a cheaper alternative. Overall I am satisfied with the Maybelline version and will probably stick to that from now on just because it really is so much cheaper.
I gave this 5 lipstick rating for packaging because I love that it comes with a brush. That definitely makes a big difference! This eyeliner though does rub off a lot easier than the Tarte version. It sometimes rubs off on the top of my eyelids or fades throughout the day. I have to reapply mid afternoon to keep it looking really dark. This has also lasted me a lot longer than the tarte version. When this tub is gone I will repurchase Maybelline instead of tarte because of the price. You get a lot of value for the price point. Good job maybelline!