"Creme Cup" is a nice baby pink lipstick which is also very wearable. I really like the texture and the staying power. And I also like that as it fades away during the day it still lives a nice pink color on the lips, which is very nice. And I would say the cremesheen lipstick finish in Mac has an amazing texture in terms of the staying power and hydration at the same time. The color is a bit toned down and a little bit lighter version of its most comparable and similar alternative lipstick in Mac. But still these differences between the two are very, very subtle. Definitely, "Creme Cup" is my favorite pink lipstick. And I know how hard it is to find a wearable pretty up-to-date and classy pink lipstick, this one is one of the kind that will look good at any age, in my opinion.
I got this since I love Shy Girl and when I swatched this next to it,it looked like a pinky version of shy girl (shy girl's pink cousin lol) and I thought oh yay! The finish even somehow looked the same. I liked how it looked and purchased it.This gives a plain pale pink color on my nc42 skin for reference. It's just a tad too light for my taste though. It didnt look awful but it didnt look that great that I would grab for it often. I love the shade when I swatch it and see it,it looks just OK on me and is slightly to pale on my lips and tone. It's pretty pigmented though. It's just a tad bit to pale on me I have found and I don't have the time to keep trying glosses to tweak it and make it work. I returned this. I love the shade though it's pretty.
I LOVE this lipstick so much! It is the first thing I ever bought from MAC and I adore it. I love its soft color and it's excellent for school. I don't like the Cremesheen finish very much but it is easily fixed with a clear gloss.
My all time favorite lipstick, followed closely by MAC's Angel and NYX's Paris. ;) I'm an NC15 jsyk.
i prefer this over angel. it is a soft, pretty pink i wear to work. it is much softer than my usual snob or gaga, etc. very pretty and creamy.
Beautiful subtle baby pink.. I have extremely fair skin and this is a great color on my skin tone. IMO it would look cheap on girls with much color to their skin but if you're fair its a beautiful pink and not overpowering. It just doesn't last very long on me but I love the cremesheen texture from MAC.
Absolutely love this lipstick, I am very pale (nw 5-10) and this looks absolutely beautiful, it's so understated. I have quite pigmented reddish lips and I use this lipstick without any liner and it gives a beautiful opaque wash of light pink.
just bought this today when I went in with some back 2 mac pots and im absolutely in LOVE. Its such a gorgeous color. To me its the perfect pink for everyday wear. I feel like it would compliment most skin tones. I did have to layer it on a bit but I have pretty pigmented lips. Overall I adore it and will continue to purchase this again and again.
I like this shade because its not too pink or bright. It is a great everyday color that I pair with a neural eye look. Love it!
I bought this because of the hype. I don't know why this has so many 'good' rates because I find it one of MAC's misses. This is a very drying lipstick IMO. I don't like the color on my lips either. Won't buy this again.