I'm very disappointed with eyeliner. After an hour of wearing it I had raccoon eyes.
.
TIP: If you don't want this liner go to complete waste, use a makeup liner brush and line the eyeliner with black eyeshadow to set it. It'll help stop the smudging. Can be time consuming though. :-|

SMEARS LIKE CRAZY. everything else about this product is nice, it creates a nice dark black line but after an hour i look into the mirror and see that it has smeared. don't buy this!

Wonderful. :)

Pretty bad. It looks good when i want something dramatic, but as you can see it smears terribly. Within five minutes itsin the corners of my eyes. I would not recommend it. Sorry Maybelline! We all make mistakes!

NO NO NO NO NO. dont buy this!!
it sucks so badly.
at first when i got it i thought it was alright and then i got it again and it makes me look hideous!! it might be alright if you only want to wear it for like 5 minutes??

it smears like crazy when i wear it out and its not really easy to apply because for some reason it just goes everywhere?? it just makes me angry!!!!

it might be okay if you only use it on the top lids and smear it, but otherwise the line it delivers is just sucky.

i definitely WONT buy this again. i like the green packaging, but it still is a sucky eyeliner - especially for NZD $18

hope you find a good eyeliner!! try rimmel or revlon, depending on how much you want to spend or what colours you want. im starting to dislike maybelline.

I got 3 words for you "SMEARS LIKE CRAZY"

CONS: smear,smear,smear,smearrrrrr >_<
as soon as i put it on,i was trying to fix it with my finger so it look even and ''clean'' .....DAMN. this thing smears like no other . I was mad 'cause i just messed my whole makeup look. The only reason i use these kind of liners because they are easier to use and faster to apply than liquid...but when i wear this,and it smears everywhereee, i spent sooo much time trying to clean up :(

PROS: very pigmented and does not IRRITATE ur sensitive eyes when you ''tightline'' :)
So once i know that it just smear smudge like that...
I dont use this liner as an liner anymore. I use it as a shadow base for my pressed powder eye shadows, this gives it a nice base and make the shadow's color more vibrant
So yea, i MIGHT buy this again
BUT do not buy this if you want an eye ''liner'' continued >>

Worst eyeliner to use on the top eye lids. Smears like crazy. Too soft of a crayon and the sharpener sucks, like all roll out eyeliners. You cannot get a nice thin line. NOT worth the money for both such a bad product and drugstore brand. Not long lasting and I don't have oily eyelids.

Save your money and buy something better like the "higher" drugstore brands such as Revlon.

This liner kinda sucks. It smears easily and gets all over the place. Application-wise I liked it though. It was creamy and went on easily, and I loved the smudge tip. But I am still in search for a good pencil liner...

I used to use this product all of the time, but even though it is REALLY black, soft, and easy to apply- by the end of the day nearly every time I find that it has smeared halfway down my face- which is definitely not attractive. Overall, this mascara would be okay if you only needed to wear it for a few hours and do not have watery eyes and do not rub your eyes but for all day the staying power was awful!

No matter how I apply my eye make-up (primer,powder,anything), this liner ALWAYS SMEARS. It leaves a line on the crease, it smudges onto my lid, and it runs. By mid-day I have shadows below my eyes. I bought this liner on a whim, wanting to try something new, but I hadn't realized Maybelline could make something so faulty. It really is too oily a liner. Period. Even if you wanted the smokey look, this would run, so what's the point? No make-up look warrants a runny liner. Too bad, though. I enjoyed how easy it was to locate because of the bright green pen.