I got mine in Black from Ulta. The colour wasnt rich enough, and the consistency very watery. Even E.L.F. was better, although i would prefer gel liners. The tip was ok, like a slanted marker. Overall, dont waste your money for this.
I got this as a gift with purchase with my telescopic mascara, so I didn't pay anything for it, which I am very glad about.
The applicator of this eyeliner reminds me of a Sephora liner I've used before: stiff, sharp and down-right impossible to get a fine and even line. I've tried applying it on an angle, straight, etc. and it just doesn't work.
The colour is a really nice rich black, but it's really pointless anyway as the applicator basically prevents you from doing anything with it.
Overall, I am really glad I didn't pay anything for this.
I got mine in carbon black. LOVE IT! The formula is awesome, very black, very easy to apply (if you're good with liquid liner) and never smudges or fades all day! The only thing I can complain about is the applicator, it's a bit stiff.
Loving this liquid eyeliner! I have been a faithful user of Lancome's Artliner for five or six years, but I don't put on eye makeup that often anymore and it dries out before I feel like I have gotten my money's worth. I have been searching for an OTC alternative, and I have found it. I love that the felt tip is very firm. I had an easy time making a thin line (don't cringe, but I lick a q-tip and use it to slim down the line if I put it on too thick) and the application was effortless. Will definitely continue to purchase. I by a brown artliner and purchased the charcoal black L'Oreal product. I like the color, but will look for a shade that more matched my artliner.
Liquid eyeliner application is definitely a well crafted skill!! If this is your first time don't give up! Practice makes perfect :-)
This is the second liquid liner I've ever tried.
I like it a lot. It's easy for me to apply but I consider my self an artist when it comes to applying make up (not trying to be cocky lol) ...I'm very patient in order for it to turn out amazing.
The only downside is that it does in fact take a lot longer to put on than if you were just using a pencil. I use pencils most of the time but on occasions when I really want my eyes to POP, liquid eyeliner does the trick!
And Telescopic is a nice one...although I've only tried 2 different kinds before...lol
This was my first liquid liner. I think its great for beginners because it has the stiff brush, so its easy to use. I take out the brush, and I wipe off the eye liner from one side of it and leave the other side just so it doesn't get runny or anything. I'm not sure if it actually IS runny, because I've always done that. Anyway it goes on nice and dark, and it stays on me all day unless I rub it. I like to wing it out a little, and if I rub the winged out parts they'll usually come off but if I rub on my lashline it usually stays. All in all, a good beginner's liquid liner.
p.s. after a few weeks its not as smooth, its almost as if it gets kind of clumpy, but only a little bit of it does that. mine usually lasts a few months, and I wear it everyday
this is my first liquid eyeliner and i'd say it is so-so for me. i like how easily applies on my lids and how it stays on me all day but the only complaint and the only reason why i wouldnt buy this again is that the color really seperates so i need to shake it first just to even out, i think this is too watery.. i'll find a better one!
Not HG material but I do like this product more than others do here. I hated the applicator at first but now I really like the thin matte line I can make when I use the side of the tube to scrape off excess and gently pat/place it on in a straight line- no swiping for this applicator.
Dont like the applicator, it makes it almost impossible to draw a thin line..you just get a pencil eraser shaped application (though not that big) to draw with. set quickly
This product is ok but nothing special I dont like the way it goes on my eyes and I find the brush is hard to control which puts on the eyeliner thicker than I would like. Its ok but I can do better