I've used the regular Big Fatty Mascara in a sampler last year and that would get a 3 rating from me. However, the Black cherry is horrible. The color barely showed up, honestly I couldn't see the mascara after a couple of hours either. My lashes didn't benefit from "big" or "fat" lashes from this product. I do not recommend it.
Big Fatty applied well and looked good on. My lashes were fuller and longer looking. It gave me about the same quality look as my usual mascara - Maybelline Colossal. The reason it gets such a low rating from me is the staying power. I only had this mascara on for a few hours and it flaked, gave me raccoon look and irritated my eyes. For all the money it costs, it should work better than my drugstore standby.
It's dry, doesn't do much for lashes. Hell, it's so dry, I can barely get it to show up!
The brush is also very, very bad. Clumps, and doesn't separate or get between lashes. Auuughh.
I was really surprised by this mascara, and even more surprised by the reviews that I've just read. I got this in the Urban Decay Trifecta (comes with this, mini UDPP, and a 24/7 liner) and didn't really expect much from it, as I only got it to try the UDPP and liner. This mascara reminds me of Maybelline's "Full & Soft", doesn't give HUGE lashes, as the name would have you think, but long, soft, feathery, and voluminous ones. It also holds a curl really well and makes my lashes really soft afterwards, like it conditions them. I haven't had any problems with flaking or it pulling a disappearing act by the end of the day, which is a huge check plus with a smiley face in my book. Overall I'd recommend this to someone who wants long, beautiful *NATURAL* looking lashes, not big fat spidery looking ones. I've had this tube for about 2 months now and it's still going strong.
Price: $20.00 USD
Packaging: Cute and psychadelic
PS - This mascara used to be about 18 bucks for a full size, but Urban Decay has since raised the price. boo=[
I bought this in waterproof black and although it does give huge lashes the product was clumping in tube and on my lashes within weeks. really bad mascara for its price unless you love huge black spider legs. regret the spend.
i got the waterproof big fatty mascara, and i just read alot of bad reviews, but i like it alot. its got a big brush that coats all of my lashes. it doesnt go on too thick, but as long as you put on a couple coats, your lashes will be think. i don't feel like its dry at all or clumpy. i love it. (a little overpriced, but so is all urban decay)
I love Urban Decay products, but this was kinda disappointing. I think because of the name (and price) I was expecting it to make my eyelashes really thick and long, but it seemed almost dried out the first time I used it. Definitely won't buy again, but I love Urban Decay!! <3
This mascara is average at best. The name and packaging is very much like Urban Decay, sassy and funky. The brush is very large, like a bumblebee, and ensures that every lash is coated. On the upside, this mascara does not clump whatsoever. It holds a curl but doesn't give much length. It also smudges under the eye. For the price ($20) it's not worth being just an average mascara.
This is the worst mascara in the entire world, hands down! Thank goodness it came in the Trifecta set from Sephora, so at least 2 out of 3 products were enjoyable. Anyway, back to the review. Now, I thought the bigger the mascara, the bigger the lashes. This wand is pretty huge. And the formula is thick, smelly, and extremely drying. ANd I cannot emphasize enough the smell!! It's like dirty pairs of socks! Please do not purchase this item. The brush did not put any product on my lashes. I had to use 10 coats to at least have a decent amount of product on my lashes. And they ended up feeling felt dry and fake. Gross. This formula is a waste of money.
I love the brush it seperates lashes and looks really dark however the mascara is very dry, i have to run it over several times to get it on my lashes. Will not repurchase.