Edit: I think I just actually just got a dud. My friend has the same color and hers works just fine.
I have this in color blackened brown #03. I chose this because I have very, very, very fair skin and generally colors like blackest black and even regular old black look drastic on me. I usually go for brown or a black/brown or charcoal color when I choose eyeliners. Had I known how little pigment this product had, I wouldn't have even bothered with blackened brown and would've gone for blackest black.
The color comes out a very light brown, lighter than a lot of the brown eyeshadows I've used. I can't even tell if it has any staying power because I can't tell if I'm wearing it because of my eyeshadow! I suppose if you're going for an extremely natural not-wearing-makeup look this might be for you, but otherwise don't bother.
Terrible. The pigmentation wasn't enough to live up to its name; blackest black. It easily comes off and is a streaky mess. I always thought Revlon products were over-priced, but this was on sale when my usual eyeliner was out of stock and I decided to give Revlon another try. Big mistake.
One word to describe this product: Awful.
This product was a huge disappointment. I got the darkest shade; Blackest Black. It is not pigmented at all! This thing was a waste of money. The color doesn’t even come out of the tip of the pen. I had to tilt it to the very side of the pen to have the color come out. Do not attempt to create a winged eyeliner look, you will just ruin your whole eye makeup look. Not to mention this smudges like mad. It even smells like one of those Sharpie pens. Will not repurchase.
not worth for the price paid. i agree with the other reviews that its not dark at all and the applicator is bad! i tried cutting the tip off mine because the liquid wouldnt even come out of the tip it would come out from the side and it just made it worse! i will never buy this again! i hope they stop production on this one because it is not worth it!!
Seriously Revlon, seriously? This has got to be the worst liquid eyeliner I've ever tried, ever. It's like a diluted, cheap, eyeliner. Terrible. Waste of money. Makes me a bit angry and yet so disappointed. I own the Revlon colorstay liquid eyeliner and it was decent. I thought this would be similar but a pen form. I was wrong.
When I buy an eyeliner shade called blackest black, I expect it to be rich, opaque black. Not watered down, sheer grey. The only thing I've done with this is swatched it, and its getting returned as soon as I go back out. Absolutely awful.
Other than the one from Icing by Claire's, this is the worst liquid liner that I've ever owned. I bought this because the drugstore was out of my regular quill-style Revlon Colorstay (which I love). I assumed that this would work just as good, just a different style of packaging...Boy was I wrong.
The pigmentation is terribly weak. If I get eyeliner called 'Blackest Black', I expect a rich, opaque carbon black...Not this weak, watery shade that needed to be layered like crazy to get any kind of pigmentation (and even then it wasn't good). You might as well just fill a vile with water, then mix in the tiniest drop of black paint and call it eyeliner.
The lasting power for this is poor as well. It smudged and transferred terribly and just accidentally swiping my hand over it wiped it away (I think it's because it's so watery). I can literally scrub at my regular liquid liners and they stay in place till I whip out the makeup remover....Plus this liner dried up in the pen really quick.
Seriously, save your money ladies -_-
I think the brush tip was a great way for me to apply liquid liner because I used to have trouble with brushes. I love the idea behind the brush tip so much that it's disappointing the liner is too liquidy, it's not pigmented enough, and it's extremely easy to wipe your eyeliner away (probably also due to the liquidy consistency). I still use this liner from time to time only for the purpose of a winged-line, because the brush tip makes it sooo easy to draw a perfect cat-eye wing, so now when I'm lazy, I use a pencil liner to line my eyes and the Revlon Eye Pen to draw the wing in the corner and blend the wing into my liner.
I don't understand all the negative reviews for this product! I absolutely love revlon eye liners, especailly this! It glids on so easily unlike regular eyeliner and it stays on all day! I would deffinetly buy this again
idk why people say its bad :/ i say this product is awesome . i bought mine in the colour black, i have been using it for a week now and its doing a pretty good job. you have good control and can make an amazing cat eye with it. i love it.the colour for me is really solid, it dries matte and stays on all day without smudging. im actually going to but another one in blackest black. hopefully it doesn't run out of ink soon. will definitely re purchase this.