this stuff, is AMAZING! :)
I have used Bobbi Brown Gel liner AND Mac Fluidline (which was a dark gray on me when I chose blacktrack), and this one is the best- in terms of COLOR, INTENSITY, LASTING POWER.... I never knew Maybelline had such great eyeliner ! WILL CONTINUE TO BUY MORE.
The consistency is creamy, SMOOTH, glides on eyes perfectly...you would NOT believe this is drugstore makeup! It lasts all day too. When I wore MAC/BOBBI BROWN it would fade over time but this just STAYS. JUST. WOW.
Go get the intense black color. It's actually pitch black, unlike Bobbi Brown / MAC (which are WASTE of money)
Let me start off with, WOW!
I am really pleased with this product. When I decided that this was something I was looking to possibly buy, I looked at a bunch of reviews. Let me say, that this is by far one of the best products I have ever bought. I've always wanted to do a dramatic top lid and even just a plain black line across the top. Something I've never been able to do with liquid and pencil liner's. The gel eyeliner is everything as it was talked up to be. It doesn't smudge. It doesn't rub off. The only problem I've found with it, is that it does tend to be a tad flakey. Nothing major though. I wore this out when me and my friends went out clubbing & when I woke up the next day it was still fresh looking. As if I had just done it. When in reality it had been on for 9+ hours. I honestly would recommend this product to anyone! :)
I haven't used this one too much yet but I got the eggplant color one and it seemed much less pigmented as others have reviewed on the black one. So I can't really say that it is bad.
It is easy to apply, creamy and the brush that comes with it is a keeper. Though I will not repurchase the Eggplant one, I might try the black or brown versions if they have a sale later. The price was just right, not too much not too cheap.
I had to work with the color and it does show up if you have patience, lovely purple. The eyeliner doesn't smudge as easily as I have thought = great!
I absolutely love this eyeliner! It definitely replaced my previous eyeliner, L'oreal HIP cream liner. It goes on extremely smooth and the line is really clean thanks to the brush it came with. Smearing, smudging, and creasing is something I did not have a problem with, even while I was sweating in today's heat. I should note that I used this product with UDPP, but I also swiped a thin line on the back of my hand to test the staying power and it held up pretty well. I let it dry and I tried to smudge it with my finger, but this liner would not budge. I have yet to find any negatives, I'm pretty satisfied with it!
What a great eyeliner, I have this in Eggplant and I love it. It lasts for a long time and doesn't smudge. I can wear it in a really thin line during the day or draw a thicker line with a small wing for night, it always looks good.
I don't like the brush that comes with it (it's too pointy and doesn't work well for me) but I have another eyeliner brush so it's not a big deal. It's a little pricey for a drugstore eyeliner but I can usually find it on sale, and it lasts for a good while. Mine is starting to dry out a little but it's not unusable. I'd definitely buy this again, I'm thinking about trying another color.
I have this liner in eggplant which is a pretty deep purple color. I love this gel eyeliner. It's so nice to apply and comes with a nice brush that I actually use! My only downfall with this gel eyeliner is that it's not as pigmented as i'd like it to be which was a bit disappointing but it's okay, I just only wear this for a day time look. I'll re-purchase.
I'm Asian so I got problems applying eyeliner on my lids. I don't even dare to try liquid eyeliners all by myself because I know it will just look awful. I bought this product just a few days ago and tried it all by myself. And hey, I really love the results! This is really awesome. Thumbs up to Maybelline for having this gel liner.
Love that it doesn't transfer on the eye lid.love the texture,the brush that they put in the packaging!that makes the perfect cat eyes!i took it in the blackest black and it's pigmented and smooth.it last fairly long,and doesn't smuge at all...wich is rare on a eye liner.i'll use that one for the night time,and keep my annabelle eye liner for daytime.update: i bought the purple one!love the color! Goes really well! Love it!
I don't understand why it's getting such good ratings I use fluidline religiously and this crap will Never!!!! Replace that. It goss on smith dries up on my lids and flakes right off!! The product in jar also seemed to dry up super fast. I like the brush it came with tho . Fluidline ftw!
First and foremost, I am an Asian. So i basically have semi double eyelid...(go figure) and applying eyeliner is super tricky for me..and i have never successfully applied a liquid eyeliner without having it smudged and transfered to the upper crease...so, i usually use the automatic pencil eyeliner..so I was sceptical when i bought this. But to my surprise this is the best liquid/gel liner i have ever tried! I dont have problem of it smudging upon application. It does smudge overtime..but its still bearable.
-has a long staying power, 5-6 hours (considering the fact that i have super-duper oily lids)
- does not smudge upon application
-and comes with great brush..trust me the brush works fabulously!
-one tub can last you a long time
-pricey for a drugstore makeup....
I love this, give it a try!
And, a few days ago, i was crying really badly (a really great touching movie, mind you), after i'm done, i went to the toilet to check on my make up and to my surprise, my eyeliner does not budge or makes me look like a panda...it looked as if i had just applied it a few minutes ago! OMG, I love this, even when i sweat like crazy this liner does not budge...i really2x love this! yippie!