Most mascaras smudge on me at some point, but this one smudges after 5 minutes. I actually threw this away.

This just might be going into the trash in a little bit. It has all the potential of being a good mascara for me, but it falls short. I don't understand. It is really thick with one of those monstrous Diorshow type brushes and yet I get no volume or length. At least none to write home about. I'm disapointed.
***UPDATE*** I kinda like it now. It is incredibly black and thick and makes my lashes stand out, but from the side. It'll do. I guess...

I got this mascara in a Stila set I bought online. I read the reviews on here before the mascara arrived so I wasn't expecting much from the mascara itself but I actually quite like it. The brush wand really grabs the lashes from root to tip and while it doesn't lengthen and thicken quite as much as I like it doesn't do too bad of a job. It doesn't clump and it doesn't smudge. I have been wearing this mascara daily to work and I would purchase again.
Update: The more I wear this the more I like it, my lashes look really great I might be back to upgrade to a 5 if my love affair continues ....

I'm really surprising myself here, but I actually quite like this mascara. In my search for the HG mascara I am always buying new ones and then after a couple of weeks chucking them out because they smudge. I have noticed that in the interim time I keep on coming back to Major Lash.

Major is a major overstatement by the way! You ain't gonna get fat, long lashes here. But, the colour is good: black and shiny, the texture is not too clumpy either. It's a good basic. There is flaking - so if that's your bugbear say no. But minimal smudging for me and I have ISSUES with smudging. I have tried all of Stila's mascaras and this one is my favourite. If you're in need of a work drawer staple - you could do a lot worse.

After a two-day dalliance with Lancome Fatale (which went right back to Sephora on account of the fact that it gave me nastylash), I find myself wondering how I could have strayed from Stila Major Lash. It is CHEAP (the $8.50 tube at Sephora lasts me a couple of months, at least), feels like I am wearing nothing at all and gives me a fantastic set of lashes.

I have short, blond, straight, skimpy lashes, and I use one coat for day and two to three at night. I always curl with my Shu curler first. This stuff doesn't budge all day for me and makes my eyes look more awake. Love it, love it, love it.

I got this in the best of stila set. I have tryed it a handfull of times, it is a good basic mascara, it lengthens a little, seperates, and gives a bit of volume. it's not waterproof. However, the price isn't worth it for me, I can find the same or better mascara for cheaper.
Might buy again but probably not.

Nothing special. It lengthens and defines, but not by much. Longer, delicate lashes. Wouldn't spend so much when a drug store brand would suffice and I would expect more from Stila. All right but not spectacular.

This adds just a hint of length and volume but it is also really dry and flakes easily and doesn't apply too smoothly or consistently. The tube opening gets messy easily and it dried out after only a couple weeks.

I hate ditto-ing a previous reviewer so completely, but makeup queen got it right; nothing special, an everyday mascara.

I have average lashes, so "nothing special" isn't going to cut it when I want them lengthened and more volume. On the other hand, when I'm doing my usual office look; sheer nudes and pinks without a lot of heavy liner, this mascara works just fine. Lashes darkened but no drama, even with two coats.

I tend to hate that breaking-in period with a new tube of mascara, so I don't know if this is going to stay wet and smeary once it has a chance to air out over the course of a few applications, but if so, it's going in the trash; I've yet to apply without some getting on my lid, no matter how far I tip my head back. I'm reminded strongly of Maybelline Great Lash so far, and that's not a good thing in my book.

I think this is a great everyday mascara...it doesn't work wonders, but it still makes my lashes look nice...nothing dramitic about my lashes while using this mascara...it makes them look very lady like...however it is one of the best mascaras that I have tried lately..I'm still in search of the perfect mascara