great long lasting liner, i like black brown one. stays all day, goes on smooth no tugging.
This is one of my favorite drug store pencil eye liners. I found this and haven't used any other pencil eye liner since. Not even name brand stuff you can find in Sephora. This goes on smooth and even and it's so easy to make an even straight line without messing up. If you are make-up challenged like me and love good quality makeup this is for you. It's dark, not chalky and see through. Easy, fast application and stays on all day. Easy to wash off. Doesn't smudge or get in your eyelid creases. It's one of those things that if you find what you love, you stick with it. This works for me so I see no reason to change. It worked for me in dry climates of California and it works just as great for me here in the very humid climate of Louisiana.
I am in love with this eyeliner. I have it in black and blackberry and they're both amazing. I expected blackberry to be more purple, but I still like the color. They're pigmented and don't smudge at ALL on my waterline (and eyeliners smudge on me EASILY). Make sure you don't retract it too much otherwise you could break a little bit of it off if you put too much pressure. The sharpener on the other end of the pencil comes in handy. I will definitely repurchase.
I like this because it does not smudge and it last longer then most eyeliners I've used in the past (i.e. Urban Decay, Stila, Milani Liquif'eye) and out of all these eyeliners I choose this Revlon Colorstay. I love that its retractable, only downfall is that the pigmentation is not as black as I expect, its more of a "soft black" rather then intense. Maybe they have a more intense black color I haven't seen yet? I don't know, if not then I hold on to my 4 star rating but will buy this again anyway.
Easy to use, lasts all day and all night, very highly pigmented, and inexpensive. I have this product in several shades and I love them all! It's perfect for a variety of uses; with this product I can choose to line below my eye and smudge it out for a smokey effect, my upper and lower waterlines, and my upper eyelid.
I use this eyeliner everyday and own several back ups. Whenever I see it on sale I pick one up. It's the best crayon eyeliner I've tried and I'm really happy with it. I use it in 'black', and the application is highly pigmented and smooth. It lasts all day and does not smudge (unless you rub your eyes). Unlike other eyeliners I've used, revlon colour stay eyeliner works in all weather conditions (including cold weather).
When I first bought this I used it until the tip went flat and blunt and it became difficult to draw a sharp line. I started to get frustrated with it and had long since thrown out the packaging. I was considering buying a new one, when by complete accident I discovered that the bottom cap can be removed and is actually a crayon sharpener! Yay! If only I'd ready the cardboard packaging I would have realised sooner lol. Anyway I highly recommend this eyeliner. It is better than a lot of others that I have tried and is great value as it lasts for a long time (approx 6 months with daily wear). 5 lippies!!
this is a good, long lasting eyeliner. it doesn't smudge under my eyes. this was especially relieving when i wore it with revlon colorstay foundation. i guess makes sense b/c it's the same line...but it's one of the only eyeliners i've found that doesn't smudge when i wear it with that foundation- maybelline eyestudio gel liner and the cover girl one i tried did smudge. anyways for the price i think it's one of the better drug store ones! i have it in brown and i actually liked the color better than i thought cos its an espresso brown
love love love this eyeliner
it's soo pigmented, smooth and lasts all day long
only con about it is the price, i paid $27 AUS which is ridiculous but it's an amazing eyeliner so would probably repurchase
I really like this eyeliner because it stays on all day. I have tried many others but you can't beat this for $5 at Wal*Mart. Right now I'm trying to use up my "other" eyeliners but I keep going back to this.
The black is very black and goes on smoothly
After seeing all the reviews here, I feel kinda compelled to write a review as well. Now I don't mean to be that one debbie downer post but honestly there are better liners out there than this one. I'm talking about the Black shade (not any of the others). .comi.com don't have particularly oily lids, and though I'm in atlanta the humidity isn't the -worst- it could be. However this liner smudges within an hour. The sharpener attached at the end also breaks the liner stick off in pieces rather than sharpen it. This liner is neater and lasts longer if you line it out with one of those spongey stiff smudging brushes and then set with black eyeshadow powder. But bottomline, save your 7-8$ and go buy a milani liquifeye eyeliner. Those things are unbelievably soft and pigmented and longlasting. Or the physicians formula shimmer strips eyeliner trios... those are crazy smudgeproof.