So the rollercoaster ride with this mascara...
I actually loved it at first... to my surprise. The tonka toy plastic wand turned out to work well, the blackest shade is quite black, and my lashes looked long and separated, and even somewhat lush. After using this a good month or so I noticed my lashes were thinning and getting shorter!!!!
Not sure if the formula pulls at my lashes during application or perhaps removal? I generally use thick/dry formulas with teddy bear wands and have never had this problem.
Tossed this mascara about 2 months ago and my lashes are slowly but steadily coming back.

There does not seem to be enough actual product in the tube and barely anything shows up on the strange plastic wand. Took too much effort to have it do anything for my lashes. I thought it was something Fisher Price might have come out with as a play thing for a little kid. Not impressed! Plenty of decent drugstore mascaras out there but this is not one of them.

I really hate the thin curved brush on this mascara but that may be because I'm not used to it. That being said, I love the way it makes my lashes look- long, fluttery and flirty. I still have to use a lash comb to achieve that look, though, and I tend to make a huge mess when I do my bottom lashes. So, I'm up in the air about repurchasing. Since I'm forever on the quest to find the perfect mascara I'm sure I'll try something else next.

Good mascara. Love the wand!!!! Good for natural-looking lashes! ZERO clumps!!!!!!!

Covergirl seems to have a good reputation with mascaras and I've tried a TON of their mascaras. This one, is my absolute favorite from them. It really doesn't clump and makes your lashes separate beautifully. I also like the slight curvature on the mascara wand because I think it really does help pull the lashes up and part them. Covergirl mascara will forever be my favorite. It makes me look super awesome! I definitely recommend this winner to everyone. I can't brag about it enough.

Like everyone else I have tried mascaras all my life -- not going to spend a ton of $$ I tried this one from reviews. I am totally sticking with this one for a long time. It does have the plastic brush thing that usually stabs be in the eye if I'm not careful, but this one is much better. It goes on nicely, I do have to make two applications but I would rather do that than smush too much on in the first place, easy to handle, nice coverage and separation without clumps. Nice product will be again.

This mascara is one of the worst ones i've tried. I picked it up on a whim and decided to try it out as i like plastic "comb" brushes. When you take the wand out, there is barely any product on it. I had to dip the brush so many times, and even then it felt like there was nothing on my lashes. It doesn't clump and separates the lashes, i'll give it that. But I did find that it flaked off which i hate. If you don't wear a lot of mascara, you might like this, but for those who like a decent amount of mascara on their lashes, don't waste your time or money on this - it isn't for you.

The pros regarding this mascara are: it doesn't clump!

It gave me more of a natural look, not too much volume or length. I curl my lashes and found this mascara did make them straighter hours later. I tend to like a mascara with more volume or thickness.

I won't repurchase due to the fact my lashes were straight hours later. Too bad because it's a nice mascara if you like a more natural defined look. At least that it the way it turned out on me (everyone's lashes are different).

Pretty good mascara. It doesn't clump that much but it also doesn't thicken lashes that much. Still, this is definitely the most clump-free mascara I've tried so far, though it DOES get clumps if you apply too many coats of mascara. I'll probably repurchase sometime in the future, but not soon. I'm going to try Maybelline's TheRocket first since I've read that they're pretty much the same as CG's Clump Crusher but also offer a waterproof version as well as thickness.

What a disappointment. My HG, Loreal Splash Out has been DC'd, so I'm always on the hunt for a new DS mascara.

My lashes are pretty good. CG Clump Crusher actually made them look bad. Instead of thickening them up, this wet formula thinned them out by getting a few to stick together so it looked like I had about five lashes per lid. I don't know what the deal was with this formula, but it made my pre-curled lashes stick straight.

I bought brown/black to soften my make-up since I'm getting a tad older, but this wasn't dark at all. It was light brown.

Luckily I had a $3 off coupon, so I don't feel like it was a total waste of money. Never again.