Eyeliner is my favorite makeup product and I have found the one I shall continue to use! I have used many brands before, even MAC, Benefit and the more pricey ones. This one is by far my favorite! It gives a dramatic look of a liquid but Is SOOO easy to put on because it is a pencil. It also lasted throughout the whole day, which never happens with my eyeliner! Will def purchase again

Looks like everything has already been said about this gorgeous liner! It's fantastic...everything I want in an eyeliner; easy to apply, dark dark black pigment and great staying power even on the waterline. A total rebuy for me!

LOVE, LOVE, LOVE this eyeliner!!!! For about 8 years, I only used MAC's Smolder. While I like how dark it is, I didn't like the fact that it gave me raccoon eyes after a few hours. It also dragged & skipped. This one on the other hand, don't run at all!! I put it on around 8am, & when I come home late afternoon, it's still there! The onlyt hing i wish i could change is it's softness. It goes down very quickly & I have to sharpen every 2 or 3 days. Other than that, this is my go-to eyeliner from now on. Plus, it's about $5 cheaper than MAC! Even Kandee Johnson loves it. I would def repurchase. continued >>

Wow! Goes on like liquid, wears like iron! After applying either brown or grey I smudge the line with the rubbery end of a Rimmel twist-up pencil and it's gorgeous.

Only quibble is that sharpening eats up a lot of product. Dig through your sharpener stash and find the smallest one so you can get a thin line without wasting so much in shavings!

This is THE HG of eye liners. Ack! I'm pretty old to have only found it now! But I will buy this again and again (w/coupons)!

This product is so amazing! it is the darkest ive used. its comparable to macs smolder...but unlike macs smolder is does not run off my face after a couple of hours. the only thing about this eyeliner is if you lose the cap it dries out like no other and is basically useless...but thats probably true for most liners. all in all....its AH-MAZING!

I was intrigued by the claim this product made -- a liquid eyeliner in a pencil -- but I really don't love it. It's VERY soft and impossible to make a thin, precise liquid-like line with it. However, the black is really intense, and when I sort of dot it along my lashline, it looks ok. I can't use it for my water line because it will smear off. It's also difficult to remove.

So this is a great liner. For me, there are 3 important things a black eyeliner must possess for me to rate is so high. Must wear without running, even without primer. Must be super black. Must be able to put it on without tugging or pulling on my lid. This pencil does all three things beautifully. Whereas MAC Engraved is black and doesn't run it isn't very soft. MAC Feline is soft and super black but smudges like hell. UD Zero is a softer black shade but the pencil tugs a bit and still smudges a bit on me. Stilas kohl pencils are very soft, but again smudges. So therefore, this is the best thing I have tired. And it really does give a gel liner look. For $8 it's a steal and def. worth giving a try. I am sure you won't be disappointed esecially since I wasn't and I've tried everything out there!

Everything has been said about this. It is an amazing eyeliner , i LOVE eyeliner, i buy all forms of it, liquid, gel, pencil. This is an amazing eyeliner, amazing color, i tell all my friends about it. YES I WOULD BUY IT AGAIN AND AGAIN!

I've heard of this through my sister and she raved about it so I decided to give it a try when I was down in Walmart Tulalip. For a drugstore brand liner it was pretty expensive, 8 usd if memory serves me right,

Anyway when I used it, I just had to line once using the Carbon black colour. It is as highly pigmented as the other more expensive brands. Unfortunately it smudges on me. :( I'm not so sure if I'll buy it again...

I LOVED this eyeliner! It is so pigmented, but unfortunately, it creates a greasy film over my freshlook colorblends. This is weird because when I was wearing the purevision brand contacts it didn't do that. I can't see out when I wear this with contacts and I used drops but it only works for a second then it's cloudy again. When I took them out, they had a cloudy film over it, you could see the grease. If you don't wear contact lenses, I recommend this, if you can put up with it breaking. That's another reason why I wouldn't repurchase, it's too annoying because it is so soft. If you can put up with that, the product is great.