Really, not a good one. Alright, you can trace it twice (although tricky to do it right without removing it) for a decent colouring (in blackest black), but the tip is not very wet (at least now it's not dry either).
Decent staying power even on bare, oily lids IF you don't rub it, easily removed when you mean it. Definitely not waterproof, smudges easily. Nice matte finish though.
By the way, I cut the tip a bit to get more while tracing, but it is easy to get a bulk tip in doing that.
There are better ones for less. It needs improvement - maybe a "blackening of the blackest black" shade would be a start. Then, the resistance to rubbing.
This product is awful! I wanted to try a liquid eyeliner for everyday use without splurging so I went to target and bought this in blackened brown. What a disappointment! This is poorly pigmented that I could barely see the color on my medium skin. An hour later, the color was completely gone! What a waste of money!
AWFUL! It pulls at the eye, skips, and is not dark. Don't waste your money.
I surprised to see so many bad reviews! This is my favorite Liquid Liner I use it all the time. It's easy to use and doesn't smudge every where. I prefer this over other liquid eye liners!
i don't understand the negative reviews for this product. i've been buying this eyeliner for four years now, and am going to buy another one today. this glides on so easily, and it's actually VERY dark and pigmented. i get a lot of people asking me what eyeliner i use because it actually looks very clean. so confused about what people are saying about this product because this is my holy grail!
The idea of a liquid eye pen is great as there is greater control over the eyeliner application. This was initially what attracted me to the product; I bought this eyeliner in Brown expecting rich yet subtle colour but was disappointed when I applied it to my eyelid the first time.
The colour comes out quite easily on my hand but on the eyelid the tip is a little hard and harsh, which makes it hard for any substantial colour to appear. After experimenting further, I figured I need a few more strokes to achieve the amount of colour I wanted. It does indeed stay on my eyelids afterwards so it does live to the 'Colourstay' name but for the price it is definitely not worth the money as there are better products out there that will perform better.
I like how the pen top clicked into place so I am assured it is completely closed but otherwise I would not repurchase as it is not a very pigmented product and would take longer to achieve the intended look than other products.
the worst eyeliner I have ever tried!
as the previous reviewer said, the tip really needs to pressed hardly to the skin to get any colour.
It's almost painful to use it!
I just bought this last week because I thought it would be easier to use than the traditional eyeliner. It is a TERRIBLE product. Barely much ink came out, it was like somebody already used it or something!! I had to press really hard for some ink to come out and in the end, it didn't look good. Never again am I buying it. What a waste of money!
Edit: I think I just actually just got a dud. My friend has the same color and hers works just fine.
I have this in color blackened brown #03. I chose this because I have very, very, very fair skin and generally colors like blackest black and even regular old black look drastic on me. I usually go for brown or a black/brown or charcoal color when I choose eyeliners. Had I known how little pigment this product had, I wouldn't have even bothered with blackened brown and would've gone for blackest black.
The color comes out a very light brown, lighter than a lot of the brown eyeshadows I've used. I can't even tell if it has any staying power because I can't tell if I'm wearing it because of my eyeshadow! I suppose if you're going for an extremely natural not-wearing-makeup look this might be for you, but otherwise don't bother.
Terrible. The pigmentation wasn't enough to live up to its name; blackest black. It easily comes off and is a streaky mess. I always thought Revlon products were over-priced, but this was on sale when my usual eyeliner was out of stock and I decided to give Revlon another try. Big mistake.