I wanted to love this so badly. But I returned it. It was very "wet" and hard to maneuver the 2nd wand. It was very flimsy. I want to try another MAC mascara but it seems like they aren't getting great reviews.

I really wanted to like this mascara but I ended up hating it. Actually every mascara I bought from MAC was a disappointment. Very clumpy,no serious volume,gets too messy,awful packaging,horrible smell...
I honestly wouldn't recommend it.

Hands down, the WORST mascara I've ever used. The pink lid is a very light mascara application and the purple glitter side is Waaaaaaaaaaaaay to clumpy and messy! Who's idea was it to creat a mascara that wraps eyelashes in tubes? It's a mess to put on & a mess to clean up - will not purchase again. continued >>

Probably my new favorite mascara, unless I find something better. I have always hated how much product comes out onto a mascara wand, and all the product I wasted wiping it off. I like my lashes to look natural and defined, with NO clumping or flaking. I am very picky with mascara.

The pink side is what I use for daily/natural makeup looks. I've used the purple one, but only when I wear dark eye makeup. It's quite expensive in Australia, but it's almost like a 2 in 1 product. I will repurchase.

Fabulous! I was recommended this mascara, and so glad that I got it:) I love the double wand power, and it really makes my lashes look great. I usually use Covergirl Clump Crusher to lengthen and separate, then Volume de Chanel to volumize. But with this mascara I have all that I need! It's a very black black, with little to no clumping or flakes. I don't find myself reapplying throughout the day because its very long wearing. Definitely going to repurchase!

I have really enjoyed this product and its "two" wand system. This is a wet formula that gets better with time, as it dries down a bit. Just beware that when you first purchase this, it is easy for you to "mess" up and get it on your eyelids. After a week of use, it is much easier to use. The "first" brush allows you to really pack on mascara in order to thicken your lashes. The "second" brush then separates your thick lashes for a more defined look. It does not flake, smudge or budge. Your eyelashes feel light and soft, no crunchy lashes here. :) It is also easy to remove with just water alone. No special makeup remover needed.

I have this in "Too Black" and love it. I use the more dramatic brush for my top lashes, and the less dramatic one for my bottom to get the perfect combination so it's not overwhelming. Doesn't smug or flake at all for me, but if you're the type of person who rubs their eyes a lot a waterproof mascara might be a better option in terms of staying power. Perhaps the only downside to this mascara is it can be hard to fully remove. For example I'll have washed my face and used an eye makeup remover, but will sometimes wake up with faint smudges bellow my eyes. Not a big deal, but proper and thorough removal is a must to avoid that. The price isn't the best but considering the results I get out of the mascara it's well worth the $20. A solid product, the best I've used and I will repurchase it in the future.

This has become my favorite mascara. Application can be a bit tricky but I think the payoff is well worth it. Using the "naughty" wand first I apply a heavy layer of the mascara and then follow up with the "haute" wand. The "naughty" wand gives my lashes the very voluminous and dramatic look that I love, while the "haute" wand gives my lashes the length that I need. This wears well for me throughout the day with very minimal smudging. Will definitely purchase again.

I love this mascara! I have short, thin lashes. The haute (defined) side is really easy to work with. Naughty is clumpy, but I feel like after I go over it with the naughty side I get a seperation and drama. Basically it's one brush, it's just that the naughty side's tube is wider so you get a ton more product. I love the haute side, you don't get a lot of excess product so you can keep it natural or build it. Big, regular bristle brush, $20.

I've heard good things about a lot of drugstore mascaras so I don't know if I will repurchase any time soon, but I like it enough to buy again.

This is my new favorite mascara! I always use both together because I like really full lashes that pop. I can hardly wear any other mascara now because none compare to the full effect I get from haute and naughty! The only down side is that if you even think about crying this mascara will be ALL OVER your face. It doesn't claim to be waterproof, but I have cried through other non-waterproof mascaras and never had much of a problem. I definitely would not recommend this if you have watery eyes! Other than that, I will def. be restocking on this one.. It's just amazing!!