Dry, crumbly and difficult to apply. Also the cap cracked right away. WnW is much better.
It's a cheap lip liner and it does what it's supposed to do. Like the previous reviewer said, the color isn't really accurate. When I bought it, I was expecting a neutral color. but it turns out to be a bright fuchsia! This was a rather good bargain considering it cost only $1 and came with a sharpener. I would purchase again, but I would be cautious with the color choice since it doesn't really reflect correctly on the packaging.
No more long-wearing or non-feathering than any other cheap lip-liner, but of course none of them are quite this cheap, with a sharpener included, so in that respect, this product's good-enough, if not good.
However, this color which looks like a plummy neutral if you see the swatch at drugstore.com reads as fuschia when you put it on your lips, so unless you're looking for fuschia, stay away from this one, which is called 'bitter.'