It irritated my eyes when I wore contacts. I think my eyes are sensitive to this stuff.
Works great at removing make-up and I love that it is not greasy at all, but it quickly dries my eye area out so I have to put eye cream on directly after use.
I picked up a bottle of this at Nordstrom Rack because it was dirt cheap ($4.50) and I have a soft spot for Too Faced products. I didn't really need a makeup remover since I just remove all my makeup with my Simple Soy Face Cleanser, but I thought it would be nice to have around in case I wanted to remove my makeup without having to wash my entire face (like if I wasn't happy with the way one part of my makeup looked).
I ended up using this to remove my foundation when I was trying out new shades, so I can't say whether it works well for eye makeup remover or if it's gentle enough for me to use on my sensitive eyes (I'll update once I know), but it didn't irritate my sensitive skin and removed my foundation easily with just some gentle wiping with a cotton square soaked with the remover.
It didn't leave my skin sticky and seems quite gentle. I'm tempted to buy more since the price is so good.
This is my favorite eye makeup remover and I'm surprised there aren't any reviews here about it yet. It's a fraction of the cost of other makeup removers (Lancome bi-facil is USD 24 and this is only 13.50) and it's oil free which is the best part. I hate the way oily makeup removers leave my skin feeling greasy. This one is cooling and it never leaves me feeling greasy. It does a great job of removing my waterproof makeup and it comes in an adorable bottle...plus the liquid is pink :)