I received this as an extra in a swap, and let me tell you, I couldn't happier. I needed a brown pencil that wasn't too light, but wasn't too harsh, and this pencil does the trick. Warms up my eyes, lasts, and it a great color!

Great liner, creamy consistency. I have now opted for brown liners as black just seems way too harsh for my blonde hair and fair skin.
This stays on my lower and upper lash lines all day, no touch ups required, yet washes off with my normal makeup remover in the shower. Love love love, I will rebuy this stuff till I die.

A perfect brown liner. Very creamy and smooth, with great staying power. I love this product, and I'm a huge liner junkie. These are my favs. It's a medium brown, not too dark and not too light, perfect.

Unlike Charcoal brown (Which is a dark brown) Suede is a medium brown matte shade that I can use on my upper and lower lash line. The staying power of these liners are great. However after a couple of months the liners got hard and hard to apply.

I can't believe I haven't written a review on this yet. It's truly HG material for me. It's the perfect taupey brown shade for me to wear everyday - I use this on my lower lash line only. I smudge it slightly with the Sephora sponge tipped smudger brush, dipped in powder eyeshadow, and I'm good for the day. The eyeliner stays put the longest of any wax eyeliner pencil on me (have tried Styli-Style, Gosh, MAC, Revlon... all those long wearing types). This pencil has probably lasted me about 5 years with nearly daily use, and I'm only more than half way through it. I will definitely repurchase - I think it cost m $6 Cdn from PharmaPlus. It's worth the money, and I will probably buy a back-up next time.

This is my HG eyeliner.I took a lippy off because it isnt waterproof.I wouldnt wear this eyeliner everyday but I would if I wanted a more natural look.Usually I use the same one everyday,but its black.

I love the Prestige waterproof pencils and this one is no exception. As the other reviewer said, this is a soft pencil, but I like that as I find it goes on easily, and is easily smudgeable immediately after you apply it, but then it stays on throughout the day. I agree it's not as dark as Charcoal Brown, this is a softer colour that is particularly great for weekends - a smudge of Suede, some mascara and Black Honey on the lips and you're good to go.

This color is among those of the type that is non-automatic and requires a sharpener.

The color of this is a dark neutral brown, but not as dark as Charcoal Brown. I purchased this as a result of the great reviews here on MUA, but I am quite disappointed with this product. I found its consistency to be too soft, making the product easily transferrable and smudgeable. Its softer consistency also makes it difficult to sharpen into a very fine point without chilling in the refrigerator first. I prefer pencil liners that will stay put on their own without having to set them with any other product, especially so that they may be used for tightlining in addition to conventional eyelining. This also irritated my eyes a bit, too, when I used it for tightlining. I paid $5 for this at Rite Aid, and I will be returning it. :-(