I love the pigmentation but the brush is kind of poor quality, for some reason mine won't let me achieve a thin line, it's quite thick. And it comes off and flakes too easily and quickly for me. Maybe this is just mine!

i don't know why, but this eyeliner didn't want to stay on my eyelids... It flaked off just after touching it once.

MY NEW HG EYELINER! After so many years of using MAC's Fluidline, being so stressed out when having to apply eyeliner, using different types of kohl pencils, liquid eye markers, gel liners and other liquid liners, nothing even comes close to being as easy as using this. The brush is perfect, its extremely pigmented and very easy to use and I can finally get a thin line with no worries! Without primer this lasts throughout a whole day with no smudges and with primer its undefeatable! I've even worn this on a hot day, riding a jet-ski which means water splashing all over me, without any primer and this did NOT budge! Very happy I found this and will continue to repurchase.

*********************HG PRODUCT****************************
This is my number one product out of any in my make up kit! If I could only choose one product to keep out of all my make up (including mascara, foundation, ANYTHING) - It would be this liquid eyeliner. I've been using this pretty much everyday for 8 years and never have I found one as good. There was a time when a friend of mine put me onto the MAC fluidline however I found myself continuously going back to my Face of Australia liner. It sells for $8.95 and lasts forever! I probably buy one every six months so it is 100% going to save you some serious coin if your used to using other more expensive products.

The thing I love about this most is the long thing brush which makes getting a 'winged' eyeliner effect so easy! Unlike other products whose brushes are short and hard to use-FOA on the other hand makes getting that 'FLICK' a piece of cake!

this is my favourite liquid liner out of them all. i have about 10 and this is the cheapest and practically the best. its brush is felt tipped so it doesnt moe around al over the place and it make is much easier to draw. i am very bad at drawing eyeliner so ussualy with my other eyeliner i just colour my eyelid in with the liner then shape it with liwuid remover and a cotton bud. thats how bad i am at drawing eyeliner but not with this. easiest eyeliner to use and i didnt have to remove any mistakes afterwards. i can say this eyeliner lasts over 9 hours.
pros:
long lasting
very black
easy to draw
easy to remove
cheap
doesnt sting
dries quickly
available in 5 different colours
doesnt flake off
doesnt transfer on the lid (good for monolids)

cons:
there are none

overall this is sos sosososososososos cheap and its i defenetly the best liquid eyeliner.

I wish I could have given this 5 lippies as I really like the pigmentation, smooth application and the thickness of the brush (super thin!) and the price... Unfortunately, this really stung my eyes and got into my eyes and rolled up into a sticky ball when I was trying to remove it (and it stung my eyes even more) with waterproof makeup remover... I don't know if it's just my eyes that are overly sensitive, but I really hate that pilling that happens with the product when I'm trying to remove it and it gets stuck in my tearducts etc... gross i know :( The revlon liquid liner does the same thing but it doesn't sting my eyes when I first apply it. So, this stings my eyes when I apply it and stings even worse when I take it off. It's a real shame because everything else was quite good about this product! Sensitive eyes beware.

Love the brush, Love the formula, Love the packaging, Love everything about it. I have used a lot of liquid eyeliners and this is one of my favorites! It lasts all day, dries matte and opaque. Amazing liquid eyeliner! I bought 2 backups!

One of the best liquid eyeliners I have ever used. The brush allows for easy application, the liquid has a good consistency and it lasts for ages! Often after a night out where I can't be bothered to take my makeup off, I find that in the morning when I wake up its still perfect. Its affordable, and fantastic :)

This was the first liquid eyeliner I bought. I just picked it randomly since it was inexpensive.
I am fairly happy with it (even though I needed a bit of practice to use it).
It was pigmented, inexpensive and the brush wasn't hard to use though it's not very finely pointed but this wasn't too much trouble.
I tried another liquid eyeliner but that didn't go so well... so I went back straight to this one.

However I wished this was waterproof since my eyes water a lot.

EDIT: This is an alright liner but I've found an even better one.

This is an inexpensive drugstore liquid eyeliner that can be purchased from priceline stores in Australia. I have it in black, but it comes in many other colours. The brush is very thin, it doesn't smudge, lasts all day, and is easy to apply, quick drying and easily removed with makeup remover.