Love love love this!! Definitely one of my HG eyeliners along with Matte Black 0L and Pearly Brown 2L. Most eyeliner pencils smudge on me really quickly. This actually lasts a good 10-12 hours on me without any smudging when I use Smashbox Photo Finish Light and MAC Studio Fix Powder as a base :) I'm NW25 and Bronze 10L is perfect for when I want a natural look that takes next to no time to pull off. I find that Champagne 23L doesn't work on me as I find it too light/bright against my skin tone. I love using Bronze 10L on my lash line and my waterline. Sometimes I'll use it in my waterline only and use another colour on my lash line. Especially in the waterline, it just adds that extra little bit of definition that makes a huge difference. Excellent product! I think $20 CDN is fine considering the quality of the product and I will definitely repurchase when I run out.
This product is OK for me. I love the color, it's perfect for bringing attention to the eyes. Unfortunately, no one seems to notice this color on my waterline. It's not that the color fades, it's because of my tan skin (NC40 for reference). This is the only good eyeliner I've tried, but it hasn't disappointed me. Overall, good product.
I used to love this eye liner - mostly the color only - it's pure gold and shine! It goes really well with hazel, green or brown eyes. However, even if it claims to be Waterproof - mine is definately not. It smears off very easily and usually I have to apply this only as underline. If I use it on top of my lids, it will be a dissaster.
Fantastic quality! I put it on my waterline and it stays put all day, which is rare for me. It subtly brightens up my dark brown eyes when I wear it like this. I love how soft and pigmented this is. I also use it as a base and it makes the eyeshadow pops out instantly. I got it in the Rock For Ever four pencils set, and I would definitely repurchase it when it runs out.
Update (3 Aug 2011): I lost my mini one during my trip and I simply found that I cannot live without it. Bought it after struggling for three days. I guess you can see how much I love it!
Provides the perfect shimmery gold/copper look I like on my bottom lashline. I don't like a dark color on the bottom as it makes my eyes appear smaller. This color is perfect for brown eyes....brings out the gold in them. Lasts all day and is super creamy and easy to apply. Washes off easily, too. My only complaint...I wish it was an automatic sharpener.
LOVE this eyeliner. goes on easy, I use it on my waterline, it lasts all day for me. beautiful color, looks darker from far away, up closer it is bronz-ey/goldish.
I got this in the mini eyeliner christmas set... Other than the fact that I broke the tip of the e/l when opening it since it was so hard to open i think the color is pretty... but I hate pencil liners that you have to sharpen... I guess i'm spoiled to the automatic ones...
I adore MUFE aqualiners! They are the only pencil liners I've EVER used that apply softly and smoothly against the somewhat bumpy contours of my upper lid line and absolutely and firmly stay put without a smudge all day! I have the 19L(basic brown) and this one. I use this bronze shade on my lower lid over the brown. I lightly run a pushbrush over the two to lightly smudge them together and work between the lashes. Some particles will drop to the endereye area, but I just lightly dust them away with the slightest dip of powder on my UD powder brush. It leaves just the right amount of bronzey sheen to emphasize my green eyes but not look overdone for a day look. My eyes water some days(allergies) and I work out nearly everyday and my e/l doesn't smudge a bit through it all. I can remove it pretty easily with cleanser and a washcloth. LOVE!!
This eyeliner works really well, but I find myself buying Urban Decay Bourbon more often.
I was talked into buying this by a girl at Sephora. She promised it would last all day and would work on the waterline. Well it doesn't. Lasts all day, yes. Glides on easily and stays put. However, this particular color doesn't go on very dark. If I use a brown shadow, you can't even see it. It also WILL NOT go on my water line. I try and try, and at most leave a very sheer line that will quickly wear off. I like to do my upper water line to make my lashes look even fuller, but this is not good for that. Plus, this pencil is pretty short, and needs sharpening almost every application, which is ridiculous for $16. I wanted to love this, but I have a feeling it will be going back. Disappointing first buy from Makeup Forever.