After years of loathing rose scents, somehow they are appealing to me now. Kurdjian is responsible for this scent, Guerlains rose Barbare, his own lumiere noire, Narcisco Rodriguez musc, and probably lots of other rose scents, and I decided that I wanted a kurdjian rose centric scent in my collection. I was hoping that this would be a less expensive substitute for lumiere noire, which I am on the fence about buying. To me, it's a bit sweeter than lumiere noire - which I find a tiny bit too sweet. Both of them somehow remind me more of fragrances like Guerlains rose nacree de desert (they are more Caramelized somehow) than they remind me of rose chypres like rose Barbare, ungaro diva or l' arte de gucci.
Someone on MUA mentioned that they got a sense of wine from this fragrance. If so, it's perhaps a "new world" type wine with a lot of fruit, not an old world wine undertone (like Frederic. Malle's une rose). Lady vengeance is definitely rose, unlike some of the "darker" ones which seem overcome by incense (tauer) or oud (lyric?) or wood (Malles POAL). Another reviewer mentioned that lady vengeance is similar to tocade - I would agree with this, in the sense that after an hour, both are roses that are honeyed. (Although tocade is sharper/harsher in opening notes). If you had to compare, I would say tocade opens most harshly; lady vengeance is midrange, and lumiere noire is the smoothest and least sweet. This is a rose perfume for those people who don't like more traditional floral or green or fruity distinct rose scents (like nahema) but do like the newer sweeter gourmand scents with a well blended rose).
So, if you want a cheaper version of this, go for tocade. If you want a less expensive, less gourmand, and more definitively rose scent, leaning towards chypre, and don't mind a bergamot opening, try ungaro Diva (buy vintage splash EdP , not EdT, and not the ferragamo reformulation spray). The dry down of ungaro diva vintage is a honeyed rose. And all of these perfumes are strong - I recommend dabbing or limiting oneself to one small spray only.
I had been debating about whether or not to buy this one for years. Every time I came across a bottle I would test it, and then think 'but I have other rose patchoulis'. Which is true, but I never wear them. I finally caved in when I found it on sale, and now I wish I hadn't waited so long. This is very much like Lumiere Noire with less skank, and on a smaller scale. Comparing the two comes down to two ways of looking at perfumery - 'perfume as art' vs 'perfume as toiletry.' As much as I love perfume, and appreciate that it is a creative expression, most of the time I just want to smell nice and not weird. LN was made for Catherine Deneuve and does indeed smell like the sort of thing you would catch on the air standing 50 feet away from where she is on the red carpet, for example. It's a massive fragrance and not something I could wear under any circumstances in my normal life. And in turn it was modelled on the type of Middle Eastern attar which seems to smell best if it's muffled by an abaya. LV is a pocket-sized version of this theme. Less skank, less sillage, more rose-y. For me that's a positive, although some will feel differently I'm sure.
I expected a deep, mysterious rose and patch combo with a bit of naugthiness or dirt, and got three hours of good old Tocade instead. I love my cuddly Tocade, however she is everything but Lady Vengeance.
Medium sillage and good lasting power though.
Beautiful scent. Very unique. Smells so luxurious. Some reviews say it smells mature but I don't think this is the case at all. It is just unique and a lot different to the sickly sweet fragrances that are being introduced these days.
I've been wearing this for about a week and I love it - it smells a bit 'mature' (like my grandma ) for the first half hour but then once it dries down the fragrance is amazing!! I keep finding myself bringing my wrists toward my nose..... It's a very sexy fragrance , very cute packaging and very expensive (but worth it)!!
I ordered a sample vial of this perfume to see if I would like it and I am in love.
The note in this perfume are fairly simple, consisting of: bulgarian rose, vanilla, and patchouli. Despite the simplicity, this is an extremely seductive fragrance. I will be rushing out to buy a full sized bottle now!
This is dark, sensual and a little bit dirty. I fell in love with this today and after swearing I would buy no more perfumes for 6 months out came the credit card. There's is something so seductive about this scent. It's mysterious, earthy and SO sexy. I probably won't be using it as an everyday scent but save it for dates or nights out as it makes me feel like doing bad things... ;) It's just bumped all my other fumes down a notch. Sorry guys.
EDIT: This has just been surpassed by "Not a perfume" from Juliette has a gun.
I ordered an entire set of sample vials from Juliette has a Gun and this was my absolute favorite of the bunch.
This to me is rose with an edge. The vanilla is not at all sweet and the patchouli is not at all strong or something that I would consider hippie-ish. It's a nice soft, inoffensive patch that gives the rose and vanilla a dark, sexy kick. As of right now this is my HG, and I have an extensive fragrance collection. The price is a bit steep so I'm hoping this bottle lasts for a while.
Also...my hubby who things all perfume pretty much smells the same, loves this on me. That's really saying something.
Love love love! It is a rather simplistic fragrance that's true, the only notes I've seen listed are rose, patchouli, and I think vanilla? Anyway I love this from start to finish, the dry down is still clearly rose but not your grandmas old fashioned rose, it is given a seductive almost masculine take by the subtle patchouli, I love it!
This fragrance is sensual, seductive, and mysterious, but with an ethereal quality - a dark, sweet, vanilla-kissed rose on a bed of warm, soft, musky, subtle patchouli, which becomes more personal as it wears. It conjures the image of a Renaissance woman in a red, satin corset awaiting her lover (or maybe that's merely my alter ego?). This is NOT my grandmother's rose, much to my delight.