This was a little too gentle for me. It removed eye shadow decently (but what doesn't?) but hardly even smeared by waterproof mascara or eyeliner. Took some serious dabbing and rubbing to even begin to loosen the mascara. I wouldn't recommend this if you wear any waterproof eye make-up.
This is the best makeup remover I have tried. I use it to remove my eye makup and it takes it right off with no tugging or constant rubbing. It feels almost like water when it goes on. It is really easy to use. Just squirt some on a cotton ball and start removing. Then splash with warm water and you're done. Sooo easy!! You can even use it to remove facial makeup as well. It is not harsh or drying and can be used for sensitive skin. My face feels so clean afterwards even if I use it alone without following with a facial cleanser. Definitely worth a try.