Not a fan. I feel like im using acetone around my eyes. Id rather dip a q tip in some remover or use a big fluff brush to fix mistakes. It feels like im tugging too much when i use this and hard to fix mistakes, if its eyeshadow fall out, then it removes my other make up as well and i have to re do. Not practical and it dries out quickly, so i am not a fan.

I don't know how it works, but it works!

EDIT: 6-6-2011
I messaged MUA about the weird person who just added mineral oil for the ingredients and they have now put the correct ingredients up. Yay!
This does not just have mineral oil...... as the above ingredient area states.
I do not know how to erase that and actually put the correct ingredients in its place.....so I will list it here for you guys.........
Isohexadecane, Cyclopentasiloxane, Isododecane, Caprylyl Glycol, 1,2 Hexanediol, Oenothera Biennis Oil (Evening Primrose), Paraffinum Liquidum (Mineral Oil), Cocos Nucifera Oil (Coconut), Bisabolol, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Extract, Tocopheryl Acetate, Propylparaben, Butylparaben

Works great...just wipe off he area cleaned with a q-tip and also wipe the tip off before putting cap on....so the color is not still on there for next time.

This really removes makeup mistakes precisely and quickly, but it leaves behind a residue so you really have to mop up after it with a Q-Tip.

well I was very excited to get this pen 'cause I read great reviews and it was only $5 but honestly I expected for much more.
I think the idea is great but it could be much better product.
when you first try to open the cup to was SO hard, I had to ask my dad to open it for me.. after a while it became easier to open.
it's basically like you just put oil on your skin, it's VERY greasy and it does remove the makeup but you need to clean the pen after every "erase" or it will really just make the area a lot dirtier..
then you should also clean the oily area with a tissue.
another thing is that if you put an eyeliner and you want to erase only a bit you can't 'cause this will remove the shadow, the base and will leave a "hole" on your lid.
it really removes everything!! I couldn't remove some eyeshadow wih my gentle eye makeup remover and then tried with this pen and it was very good!
I'm not sure I'll be buying it again but it's nice to have it in your makeup bag esp for that makeup dirt that sometimea can be under your eye because of the mascare or the eyeliner.

Essentially a makeup remover in pen-form. I believe it's around $8 CAD in drugstores. I've bought this twice and still not convinced. I believe this product is supposed to be swiped on mistakes, then followed up with tissue to remove the residue. I did that, but it still smudges my other makeup when I'm not careful. It's convenient, though. The dealbreaker is that the tip breaks off much too easily - it happened to me each time. Not repurchasing.

I love this makeup eraser pen because I can fix my eye makeup mistakes and smudges during the day. It's a girls' must have! Although when I use it on my eyes, theres a slight stinging, it goes away when you wipe the area with a tissue after using the pen so it's okay.

Usually I wait a while before writing a review of anything, but I couldn't wait to write this one. This thing is so awesome. It's like a tide to go pen for your face.I always mess up my mascara, and thanks to this little gem, my frequency of yelling curse words will be going down.I am amazed that it can remove little mistakes without messing up the rest of my makeup. It's the perfect size, and it's so user friendly. Now, since I found this at Winners, I'm assuming it's been discontinued so I may have to search ebay for backups since I haven't seen them anywhere else which sucks,but oh well.

This pen is amazing at erasing those many eye makeup mistakes, but it's not for those with sensitive skin! Lately it seems to burn the skin around my eyes. So I will have to find an alternative.

I love this, because I tend to get raccoon eyes from my mascara during the afternoon, and I was worrying about having to carry around a bottle of makeup remover and q-tips all the time. This clears up any sign of raccoon eyes, as well as if you make a mistake on your eyeliner. The only thing that kind of bothers me is that the cap on mine is really hard to get off sometimes, but it could be just mine. I love this so much!