This eyeliner runs easily, and fades quickly even with eye primer. Unfortunately I wouldn't recommend to others

Pot lasts forever and does not dry out! Very smooth and creamy, but don't use the brush it comes with - it's not a very good brush. Color is solid and intense, with the right brush it can be very nice.

Can't really use it on your bottom waterline though.

Wouldn't purchase again but that's because I prefer pencil eyeliners more.

I have the black and deep brown. These are my favorite eyeliners hands down! I use the black for more dramatic/ night time looks and I use the deep brown as a daytime eyeliner and I also use it for my eyebrows and let me tell you it is the bomb for filling in eyebrows. The consistency of the formula is nice and creamy. It goes on very smooth. Clinique is such an amazing brand and they deserve more hype than they get.

I love this eyeliner because it stays on 8+ hours for me without budging. You'd be better off with a different brush. My favorites are the white Sonia Kashuk bent eyeliner brush and the black ELF slanted eyeliner. I recommend dabbing a little off the brush onto your hand before you apply because a little goes a long way and this stuff is hard to get off without messing up everything on the lid. Then you can use what's left to build up your line.

Great cream eye liner!! I love this stuff. It goes on great unlike some other ones that I have tried. I don't usually wear black liner on my eye lids but I do like to wear dark brown and this color is perfect. It goes on so smooth and you can do a perfect line with this liner without ANY smudging. I'm so glad I finally found a perfect cream liner and will definately repurchase. :)

This simply just does what I need it to do. I have dark brown, slightly slanted eyes and a nice thick line on my upper lid and I get a natural doe-eyed look. It's less harsh than a black liner, and my eyes look SO much bigger!

I do take a lippie off because of staying power. After maybe 5 hours it starts to fade/melt off my eyes, and after 9-10 hours sometimes you can barely tell its there. Granted, I have oily lids, but I've used cream liners with better staying power (ie Smashbox).

Application is a little strange sometimes. I use my own slanted liner brush and sometimes you wipe some of it off when you go over the line more than once. However, once you get a hang of it it's a breeze. I use this pretty much everyday in my morning makeup rush.

Good product, fair price. Would buy again.

Hate to be the lone dissenter, but this smudged quite a bit on my oily lids. It is creamy and goes on smoothy. Also did not care for the brown shade, itīs not quite dark enough.

It is a pretty color, but it seems to be more watery than the true black version, so I had to use twice as much compared to when I had it in true black.

This is a very good eyeliner. The brown is very dark but it's obviously not black.Will not budge once on so be careful when applying.I use this on my upper lid and still use yohl on the lower as I find this is too harsh under the eyes.Depends what look your after I suppose.Wouldn't recommend for water line though, would leave that to the pencils.

Love this eyeliner. It glides on smoothly and lasts all day with no smear. I had one for over two years and it still hasn't dried. Definitely worth the price.