I've been using this mascara for over 5 years. I bought it in transparent color, I don't use it as mascara but as eyebrow gel, works like magic!! It tamed my unruly brows and only had to be touched up once during the day.. but sadly, etude has discontinued the clear one, only avail. in black and brown. What a shame..now I use the clear blue mascara ( I don't know the name) for my brows. But if only they produce this back, I'll stock up for sure..Great product!
the formula is a bit too dry. it does gives volume, definition and good separation though. good for people who want natural lashes look, but i want my lashes to be noticeable. so i wont buy again.
Got 2 GWP tube of this mascara, ended up giving them up to friends. I've successfully used this only one time, other times it just get clumpy when I tried to build it. 1 coat only seems ok though, a bit volumizing, and the black color is bold enough to make lashes stand out more on photos. No smudges or flakes.