It's so hard to find a good, deep, plummy eyeliner these days, so I was excited when I saw this at Sephora. This Pearly Waterproof Eyeliner pencil had so much promise. The color looked gorgeous - even the name is beautiful and what I'd hoped it would be...a deep shimmery plum. Ironically, it does go on smoothly, but the color goes on splotchy because the consistency is so waxy - too waxy. Lasting power is so-so. I expected much more from a pencil that costs more than MAC's powerpoints/kohls. Thumbs down on this one.