This is a frosty/icy pale, pale pink. The texture is very light and a little too slick for my liking (not appropriate for a lip liner in my opinion). It looks a little weird on me, though it does okay as an upper lip highlighter a la Guerlain's Cupidon, though it's more obvious. Inexpensive and comes in a handy, twist-up design, but I wouldn't repurchase as I've no use for it.
Pink Sugar is a veryyyy light pink - think MAC pretty please l/s. I guess its okay for lining lips when you want a light pink lip, but its very sheer and hasnt got any staying power. Ill finish up but wont buy again - still looking for HG light pink lipliner.