This eye pencil is so waxy like a crayon and never comes off! It is not smooth at all and i have to tug on my eye to get it off. It also smells terrible! I dont know why mine is so different from the other reviews. I really wished mine worked.

this eyeliner is easy to apply but i smuges and runs easily.
it's not long till i found out i look like a panda. i do not like it alot

I have this in a light silvery mauve color. I love this pencil. Just used it today to highlight my inner corners and this applied super smooth and pigmented. It also lasted all day which is a true feat on my super oily skin. For $5 Im very impressed. I will probably try more in the future.

I really liked this product, and for the price, it's definitely a bargain. I also use this as a base for my eyeshadows, and it works very well. You do have to keep in mind that it'll crease if you don't blend the color well, though. I find the crayon works best if you apply it all over the eyelid, and then grab a brush (preferably a sturdier, more firmly-bristled one) and blend it. To prevent it from further creasing, apply a medium layer of powder shadow on top (not to thick or too sparse! Either of these will cause the crayon to crease) and the color should stay, for a few hours at least.

I have a purple one from this line. I use them as a base for my MAC eye shadows. It really helps the colors pop! I used the purple one with MAC's lovely lily pigment, stars n' rockets e/s, and satellite dreams e/s and it was so bright and lasted all day and night! I will be buying more of these.

I have this in #502 Beige, and I love it. It is a nice neutral beige color with light sparkle. Not too chunky. I use this on top and bottom lids after applying darker eyeliner, and it really brightens up my eyes! Love it, and will be buying more!

This is an ok eyeliner. The black is a very true black, unfortunately it smudges quite a bit. I have a problem with some eyeliners wearing from my lash line to my eyelid, and this was no exception. However, if you don't have a problem with eyeliners doing this then this would be a great cheap eyeliner.

So far, I have been very pleased with everything I have purchased from the Sephora line. I think that everybody underestimates it because the prices are lowers than many of the brands that are sold at Sephora, but I think that the products are far superior than many more expensive brand-name makeup at Sephora. The Sephora crayon eyeliner pencil is probably one of the best buys I've ever gotten from Sephora. It was reasonably priced, and it's an amazing product. The color comes on so easily, and it stays on for a while, which is pretty rare for eyeliner. They have them in every color, so I would suggest that you get the ones that highlight your eyes the best. I have them in black,green, and purple and I will absolutely will re-purchase when I run out, which I'm pretty sure I will, since I will most definitely be using these quite a lot.

Way too hard to use as a liner - tugs the eye and does not leave enough color to be noticeable. I would rather pay the extra money for Sue Devitt's eye intensifier pencils.

I loooove these, they are too light for me to wear alone as eyeliner but they help tremendously when I want to smoke something out. I put it over eyeliner I already have on.