I have always been a lipliner fan. I have tons of different ones. When they came out with the new sheer liners(smashbox sheer)/ glaze liners(stila)/ cream shapers(clinique), i got even more excited. The newer formulas today are super soft. They make all other lipliners look dry in comparison. Smashbox sheers are fantastic. Super soft and silky with no tugging. Content is a soft browned berry. Very natural. Not as scary as the color coordinating end looks. Retails for $14. Great formula.