I have always been a lipliner fan. I have tons of different ones. When they came out with the new sheer liners(smashbox sheer)/ glaze liners(stila)/ cream shapers(clinique), i got even more excited. The newer formulas today are super soft. They make all other lipliners look dry in comparison. Smashing Outline is a light shimmery pink. Too light for my darker lips. Pretty shimmery pink color though. I wont repurchase but nice color for someone fair.