On me, this is MAC Expensive Pink in cream pencil form. I like it, but not enough to replace a powder with it. It's meant to be a stand alone color, but is supposed to help as a base as well, but I find that it creases terribly on oilier lids. Fortunately creasing isn't a problem for me, but the texture of this leaves something to be desired - it doesn't glide as easily as it should, so applying it feels like I'm literally dragging a Crayola over my lids. Because of that, I don't wear it as wash, but I like it on the inner corners as a wake-me-up.