A bit smudgy but good for a dark, smoky eye. I love kohl liners and this one is inexpensive and works as well as more expensive brands.

This is great for lining your upper eye, but NOT for lining under your eyes like I do or your waterline.
I got this pencil in black and brown. I use the black one for above my eyes and the brown one for under my eyes, but I'm thinking about giving the brown one to my younger sister and buy a more expensive long lasting pencil for under my eyes.

The colors are great though and it goes on very easily.

So i'm very in the middle with this. for your upper eye lashes it's a YES YES YES
for under your eyes it's a NO NO NO

I really like these eyeliners! For the price I think they work pretty well and stay on the waterline way longer than I would have expected! They also are very soft and don't irritate my eyes. Only problem is the tips ten to break off easily, especially when sharpening.

I stole this from my mom. ^-^ I loved it, so I picked it up on drugstore.com for really cheap. I got the black and white. They both last all day for me, although I just use the white one for an eyeshadow base and an inner corner highlight. I put it on my waterline and it doesn't last for very long. I use the black on my lower lashline, and waterline if I'm going for a raccoon-eyes look. Very creamy, although they do break so you have to dull them out. For the price, amazing product!

As soon as I tried to apply it (it comes sharpened) the tip completely broke off. So I tried to sharpen it, and it's really hard to sharpen to a point without it breaking.

The colors available for this kohl pencil are a good range.
I am hesitant to apply the pencil at the waterline again, as it made my eyes slightly itchy. Also, it does not brighten the eyes like natural kohl does. Overall, it causes a rather dull effect.
The kohl tip can not be sharpened easily. It breaks.

Yes, overall it does serve the basic purpose of creating some color around the eyes. I'd rather prefer the natural kohl product and wish it were available in other shades.

This is a makeup bag essential for me. It's the best basic eyeliner, and I love smudging it on my top lash line for a natural smoky finish. I add it on the bottom of my eyes and in my water lines for a more dramatic look. Also a perfect beginners eyeliner!

Was looking for an easy to use water liner. So easy to use, good for a beginner like me. Shows up well. Doesn't irritate my eyes noticeably.

[edit]
smudges

I now use this for my eyebrow pencil, alongside the brown one, to give depth and shading. i love this, its soft, doesnt smudge AND lasts for ages, unlike the benefit brow pencil which is SO soft that the pencil lasts about 2-3 weeks if that!!!
Love this, one of about two products of theirs that i do like!!!!

It's a nice pigmented color, but it smudges like crazy after two hours or so. Will not buy again.