I dont like any of the NYC mascara. It clumps and it doesnt even work. The product doesnt even get on the eyelashes. And its dry! Not worth it.
Very cheap - bought at walmart for $1.72. Works great except the MAJOR raccoon eyes. I would use makeup eye remover and then wash my entire face... STILL left with all the junk underneath my bottom eyelashes. Only thing that would remove was a DRY piece of toliet paper... which by the way that is the most delicate area of skin on the human body so rubbing with anything rough and dry...not good!! this mascara found a great home... in my garbage can. Not going to continue use if my night routine is increased x 10. Overall: Just to difficult to remove!!
I have been on the search for the perfect "holiday" mascara ever since all the ones in Sephora went OOS. I knew this one was not a glitter one but it did promise a hint of holiday shimmer and since it was LE I grabbed it right away. I cold not wait to try it. Huge major disappointment. There is no shimmer what so ever, not even a hint. I really wanted to like this and even used a close up mirrior and layered and layered, hoping to se some sparkle. Nope nothing. Just an ordinary black mascara. It was only $4, but I wish there was even a hint of shimmer to it. Don't waste your money if you are looking for a shimmer mascara