Color and consistency were OK at first, and the waterproof(-ness) was great. However, after a few weeks it became noticeably more clumpy. I won't buy it again. If the initial results had been spectacular it might have been worth it.
This is an average, basic mascara. I have very sensitive eyes, and it does live up the the claim of it being good for sensitive eyes. However, it flaked and left dark circles under my eyes fairly early in the day. It's kind of clumpy too.