The Rouge Sensations are nice lipsticks, being very pigmented, creamy and emollient-feeling. However, I dislike the rose scent that Lancome puts in their lipsticks, so I deducted a lippie. Sometimes the scent is quite strong and sometimes it's bearable, but generally, I don't like having fragrance (esp. non-foody) in my lip products. "Arbor Rose" is a deep, slightly bricky, dark red. Got this as an extra from a lovely swapper but I doubt I'd purchase one as I think this color can be easily replicated in DG brands.