I have hair dyed black. Black liners tend to look really fake in my brows. So I use dark brown and it looks pretty natural. I use this liner and an angled brush to apply it. It looks nice and lasts all day.
5/24/12 update: I have since switched over to Milani. This does smudge and move a little through out the day. Meanwhile Milani does not move at all.

This is a review for the color MINK. This is a great little eyeliner. I use it to fill in my brows as well as line my eyes.
Its a very soft pencil which has a tendency to smudge , so I definitely use it more when I am expecting that to happen. Of course it smudges more in warm weather than cold and I wouldn't use it to heavily line my eyes for a night out, as I don't think that would work very well with the smudging.

All in all, I always use it up and reach for it everyday.

Horrible. i bought it because of the reviews here, but it wipes right off after application, and won't even apply to my waterline. will not be repurchasing:(

This is the best waterproof eyeliner pencil for the money ($2-$3). Prestige also makes good eyeliner pencils but they are harder to find. These are so popular at my local Target that it's always out of stock.

Make sure to get the waterproof version, not the cheaper version, they are not the same. For some reason the waterproof version is leaps and bounds better than the other version.

I use the Dark Brown on a daily basis for work. I also have the black which I wear on the weekend or to parties. Dark brown is a rich, dark brown. Black is very black which is too harsh for wearing to work. For the price, you really can't find a better eyeliner pencil. You can buy 5 of these for the price of one MUF eyeliner.

I own several of these eyeliners and I love the dark brown just as much as the others. The price is awesome for the quality! I have been purchasing these eyeliners for about 7 years now and I just low the results and staying power. My only compliant is that they don't apply as smoothly as some of the higher end liners do.

I will never spend more than four dollars on a dark brown eyeliner again thanks to this little beauty. I wore it for 12 hours without any noticeable fading, and the color payoff and ease of use are on par with expensive brands found at Sephora. I didn't wear it on my waterline and removed it pretty easily with warm water and my regular facial cleanser, so I can't vouch for it being waterproof. But if you need a good pencil for cheap, this is it.

This is a review for NYC waterproof eyeliner in Mink (which looks like dark brown). I've been using this eyeliner for more than a year and I couldn't give it higher marks. I had previously used a Clinique eye liner, but started looking for a product that was less expensive. I read the reviews about this liner and thought I would try it out. I couldn't be happier with it and with its price. I have oily eye lids and I live in a hot humid climate and it stays on. Great product at a great price! The shade of brown also works well for me, as I don't like overly dramatic eyes or like looking like I'm wearing a lot of make-up.

I've had a stick of this fovever and i lost it and then found it and fell back in love with it. Like another reviewer who gave a completely horrible review I have oily skin and wear contacts but it doesnt budge on me. I went on a 2 hour walk came back all sweaty and oil and it still looked amazing. GET IT. And the plus side is its cheap. :D

Ok, I had really high hopes for this eyeliner... even though it was cheap. My skin is very oily and I wear contacts so its hard to get eyeliner to stay for more than a few hours. The smudge end on this liner is what hooked me. I love a smoky eye... after a few hours this product made me look like a racoon. The product literally slide off my eyelids. If you have combination or dry skin this would probably be a great product. However, I won't be repurchasing and suggests those with my skin type don't buy it either.

On a scale of 1-10 this is for sure and 11! It is an awesome standard pencil eyeliner. It has very good color payoff, you can tell they packed lotsa pigment in there. What really blew me away was how smoothly this glides on, it just rolls on basically. It stays on all day, and comes off easily with eyemakeup remover. And for only $3 its a steal!