Ok, this was only a dollar; I have been trying to remind myself, you get what you pay for. For a dollar you get a lot of product, considering Stila's click pens can cost up to $20. Overall I hate this product.I love the color, but that is about it. The click pen works and sometimes it doesn't, it can take up to five minutes of continous turning to get this stuff out, and the felt on the pen wears off pretty quickly. Which isn't a big deal if you like little fibers stuck to your lips. Also, the formula needs a little improving. Again, the color is nice; I got this in bitter, which is a nice raspberry color. But this stuff smears so easy and it bleeds. I have never had a problem with any type of lip products traveling. There is also a weird sweet medicine odor to this...so for a buck I guess you can't beat that, if you are just experimenting but I wouldn't add this particular product to my everyday bag.
Very nice sheer, shiney, mauve color. I actually HATE click pens but this was free with purchase. It actually came up nice and did not goo all over the place. No real smell or taste and the cap stays on well. One of the new products.