This is the only liquid liner i will ever buy. I've tried the maybelline stilletto, mac liquid pens, elf liquid liner. I always go back to the old fashion liquid liner by maybelline. It has a great applicater and the product lasts FOREVER. I just bought a new liner but i swear the last bottle i got lasted me for 8 months or longer and i use the product every single day.
I think the product might crease on eyelids if you have greasy lids but i wear a light eyeshadow everyday and a primer and i dont have any issues. i really hope they dont discontinue this product anytime soon.

This was one of the liquid eyeliners that I always bought when I was a teen. I think it works okay, but not fantastic, especially for someone like me who has greasy eyelids [in a tropical climate, too!]. Doesn't stay very long, or as long as I would like it to be. But the price is pretty affordable. I've always re-purchase this over and over again, until I tried their gel liner... And then I never looked back

My very first liquid eyeliner. I used this as a teenager and mastered the cate eye using this product. It has decent staying power and a nice, smooth consistency. I might have to try these liners again.

easy to apply
non irritating
quick dry
nice black color
cheap

I have the liner in the second picture shown (blue/black packaging with felt tip). This is one of my favourites because it doesn't dry shiny like others I have tried, no cracks/flakes and is smudge-proof. I have oily lids and this doesn't budge from my top lash line one bit. The only problem is that it is slightly watery so I have to go over a section twice to get it really intense in colour.

I agree that the tip is pretty good for a precise or a thick line. I am very bad at controlling, so if I use a too-soft tip, I can never do it. Therefore, it is a plus about this product.

However, today, when I put it on my make up which lasted from 2:30 PM to 7:00 PM, I did not realize that it had melted on my eyelid. When I went home and looked at myself in the mirror, you can imagine how horrify I was. The weather is very good today, not too hot, you can say that it is warm, and I did not sweat. With this finding, I am in doubt about the "staying" power of this product, and would not purchase it again.

It is very easy to clean off, though. I just scrub my facial cleaner on the line when I closed my eyes, washed with cold water, opened my eyes, and it was gone. It does not leave a flaky or some other black stuff that I experience with other Maybeline eyeliner.

Great eyeliner! It doesnt transfer when your eyes are open for a long time and is VERY easy to apply. I can do both eyes in like 3 seconds. I do use Urban Decay Eyeshadow primer potion so that might be why it stayed on so good. But i love it!

I run out of my liquid liner, and bought this one in a attempt to try something new...well it sucks!..the color fades quickly, after 2 hours, and the product itself was like too liquid, I could see the clear water and the color separated!...I will stick with my revlon colorstay.

The liquid eyeliner SMUDGE!!!!
It cant last me for the whole day... I prefer the other hard tip eyeliner from Maybelline!

this liquid eyeliner has staying power..sure it has that but when i tried to clean it off, it gets flaky and worse still, some of the black flaky thing gets into my eye. oh wow. perfect i thought. i bought it after reading the reviews by others and i thought why not try it out. oh dear. it's a waste of my money n i'm gonna give it to my friend. besides that, i think the pen is kinda thick and don ever, i mean never ever open your eyes before it dires or else..you'll look like a robber wearing a black eye mask or something. i'm gonna stick to the good old pencil instead.