I like this quad. I definitely like "gleam" and "pickle." Mystery is a nice brown, but I am still having problems with brule. I don't really know how to use it. All in all, I dont think all 4 of these shadows should really be used together. I'd use gleam, myster, and pickle together, but even then I have a hard time knowing where to put gleam. I tried lining my eye with it but light colors make my eyes look small. So I dunno... you're definitely safe with just using pickle and mystery together.