These must be new. I saw them for only $2.99 and thought why not? I thought it was powder but it's a cream eyeshadow. I bought #98863 which is a sage color in the bottle but on my eyes it turns into a chartreuse color with yellow undertones. I love the color but the rest of it sucks. The packaging is worthless. The sponge applicator is worthless. I had to use my finger to apply it which still didn't work right. Plus not even 10 minutes after I did apply it, it started to crease. Just all around worthless.