I adore this Lip Liner by Este lauder in Chocolate.It gives any tone lips such a defined look the color is a deep brown with red tones in it, almost all shades of lipsticks fit this liner, even lipglosses.I lover the swirl twist to get the pruduct out, and it comes with a refill.I purchaused it for 15.00 at a CCO they still sell them at the regular stores but more expensive 24.00, kinda hefty but it is totally worth it.

I love the fact that you can swivel these up AND down. I hate the ones that only work one way. The price is okay when you factor in the fact that you can keep the base and just buy refills (in different colors etc.). The color is awesome, a nice chocolately brown. I use it for nearly everything (deepens brighter shades, good for night looks, etc.)

This is an amazing and versatile product. The color is rich and deep, which beutifully complements darker skin tones yet isn't overpowering or garrish, so it's an excellent day to night lipliner. Although, the price is on the steeper side ($24), my only consolation other than the lipliner itself is that refills can be purchased for $8 afterwards. This is definitely a keeper.