This is the first lip liner, and works great as a lipstick. It's a very pretty nude color that is creamy and gorgeous and goes well on almost anyone. I love that it doesn't smudge and has a long staying power. I highly recommend.
This is the perfect nude-pinkish lipliner. It was recommended to me on MUA makeup board when I asked for the "perfect nudey-pink liner". Well, it is!! And it glides on smooth, too. Not hard and difficult like MAC Spice. Plus I like the color of this better than Spice- Spice looks too orangey or corall-y for some reason.