I actually like this much to my surprise especially the waterproof side.I like this more than the original volume express mascara by maybelline and that one 11 $.This isn't waterproof or water resistant in the slightest but it gives my amazing length and curl.I plan on buying another when this one runs out.

Horrible. I never seen such a drying mascara ever.
The first time i opened it, I felt as if I had this mascara for years and ran out of product.
I basically bought a mascara wand since nothing actually went on my lashes.
I now use the brush when I take a break with mascara and apply vaseline on my lashes instead.

H O R R I B L E

This mascara was okay I guess. I only used it on my bottom lashes . I love this mascara sooooo much when it comes not dried out. But seriously I brought 4 of these and only 1 didnt come dried up and crusty. So i wont repurchase just because i just have to take it back anyway because i cant seem to get one that isnt dried up.

I do not like this mascara at all. Its drying, goopy, doesnt do much, & is basically awful. continued >>

Love the regular side (till it dried out). Hate the waterproof side.
At first it was so goopy and etc. (Like most mascaras I use) and it clumped so much! However, after a few uses and using a spoolie to get rid of the clumps, it's fine. Great for natural looks (darkens, not dramatic lengthening or volumizing).

It washes off so easily with soap and water, so that's a plus. This mascara takes some effort to look good, so if you're into the whole "natural lashes" look, this is for you.

Personally, I rather go and try other mascaras so I doubt I will be repurchasing it.

For me, this mascara was awful. The regular side was dry and flaky on the first usage, and the waterproof was SOOOO droopy and clumpy, but dry as well at the same time. It was so bad that I never put the waterproof one on my lashes. As for the regular, apart from the flakiness, it looked like nothing had happened. It didn't even look like I was wearing mascara. In my opinion, don't waste your dollar on it.

I only give this 3 stars & I would purchase this again because it's so.... basic. The only reason I would repurchase this is because it's $1 - It doesn't clump, it doesn't thicken & it doesn't lengthen (much) - it just coats. It's ok for a natural look and just want your lashes coated.

I have long lashes already so basic black lashes don't bug me.

It's not my MAIN mascara, but it's good for those "just in case" reasons. continued >>

Oh gosh, I hated this thing! For the price, it's not terrible. I like the colour and how easily it goes one. It's pretty awesome in that my lashes felt soft and touchable after wearing it. The smell is pretty bad, but not as terrible as some others, but the worst thing is the flaking. I have a habit of rubbing my eyes, which I try hard not to do when I'm wearing eye makeup, but I forgot and rubbed one eye. So much of it flaked right off! It got everywhere and was incredibly gross. It doesn't lengthen or thicken very well, either.

Both of the mascaras are good, and it's great to have the advantage of being able to have both a regular and a waterproof mascara in one!! The result is fine, even if it doesn't really give you amazing lashes, it really makes them look gorgeous.

Its soo gross thick and chunky i regret buying this along w/the set that it came in. it really is cheap quality,sucks.