I bought this off Sephora.com because it sounded amazing...but, it isn't. I completely agree with the other reviews...it smelled horrible. Like menthol. Right back it went. Blech.
I wish I had read groovynub's review before placing my order. Watermelon Slush does indeed smell more like menthol than fruit. In fact, I could only detect an overpowering minty/medicinal smell when I opened my tub. This is going right back to Sephora. For $16 I wanted sweet Watermelon Jolly Rancher, not Vick's Vaporub. My Totally Juicy sugar scrubs have a more realistic fruit smell than this crap, and they are definitely cheaper. Bleh...avoid unless you love menthol. They should rename this, calling it Watermelon is very misleading.